Pea-n-Me
DIS Legend
- Joined
- Jul 18, 2004
- Messages
- 41,912
I apologize for taking so long to get back.
I'm trying to read through my chicken scratch, hopefully I can get this right.
PrincessinOz: #776, yes. Pail and shovel, ok. I'm tempted to give you double points for getting an Octogenarian Equestrian in riding gear, also (just kidding!). I think it was your Baseball Stadium in 773 (or whosever it was), sorry that's a no. Your Illusion is ok.
jmskinner: yes to Barnacle, #732; sorry, no to Newborn for seahorses.
RMDavis: I couldn't find your reference to #690. #683 yes for Antique. Two of your shots made for an interesting debate in my house (I bounce these of my DH): the root beer shot and the Mountain Dew shot. Not trying to embarrass you at all, but citing this to show why allowing some of the "stretches" (in general, not with yours, necessarily) leads to difficulty. I really don't want to allow your Mountain Dew shot for Dew because Dew was intended as morning dew on something outside. I've been impressed with how even some of the people newer to photography have gotten these shots (I'm picturing them down in the grass at daybreak trying to figure out how to get the shots; I haven't even attempted one myself yet!). But because I allowed some of the pictures of the words Eclipse, I feel like I have to now allow the Mountain Dew shot. (Next year the wording in the rules on these will be more clear, live and learn for this year.) What would make me really happy is to see you replace the Mountain Dew shot with a real Dew shot.
As for the root beer shot, well I loved the shot itself but was torn about whether it should count because the intent was regular beer, however your shot was nice and frosty, which did meet half the requirement, at least, and it was a beer. Decisions, decisions.
DH, btw, says no (even though he has pleasant memories of root beer from Dog n Suds); I say yes. So yes it is. (Next year I'm hiring an independent judge!)
I would be interested to hear what others are thinking here. I just hope you can all appreciate the difficulty of trying to be fair here. (I know you can, you've been a great group!)
tazdev: debate about your locomotive, also.
Will not be able to allow it as we have to see a train that holds freight, sorry.
Stargazer: boiling tomatoes, not seeing the sizzle, lol. Show us something else - in the frying pan or on the grill, etc.
funkychunkymonkey - I am unsure if your cow is a Holstein in #815 - can anyone verify?
dizneydaz - #837 Celebration of Independence - please show something 4th of July related (I know you said it was your way of celebrating, but that could have been anywhere, any day, etc). Rollercoaster - that was taken from the top, I believe, then it counts. Unusual mirror, sorry, no - the mirror itself needs to be unusual or ornate. #842 Please explain the Win. Also Kite - is the name of the ride the Kite? (I was looking more for a handheld kite.) Great job finding an ox bow, I didn't know if anyone would get that!
I'm trying to read through my chicken scratch, hopefully I can get this right.
PrincessinOz: #776, yes. Pail and shovel, ok. I'm tempted to give you double points for getting an Octogenarian Equestrian in riding gear, also (just kidding!). I think it was your Baseball Stadium in 773 (or whosever it was), sorry that's a no. Your Illusion is ok.
jmskinner: yes to Barnacle, #732; sorry, no to Newborn for seahorses.
RMDavis: I couldn't find your reference to #690. #683 yes for Antique. Two of your shots made for an interesting debate in my house (I bounce these of my DH): the root beer shot and the Mountain Dew shot. Not trying to embarrass you at all, but citing this to show why allowing some of the "stretches" (in general, not with yours, necessarily) leads to difficulty. I really don't want to allow your Mountain Dew shot for Dew because Dew was intended as morning dew on something outside. I've been impressed with how even some of the people newer to photography have gotten these shots (I'm picturing them down in the grass at daybreak trying to figure out how to get the shots; I haven't even attempted one myself yet!). But because I allowed some of the pictures of the words Eclipse, I feel like I have to now allow the Mountain Dew shot. (Next year the wording in the rules on these will be more clear, live and learn for this year.) What would make me really happy is to see you replace the Mountain Dew shot with a real Dew shot.
As for the root beer shot, well I loved the shot itself but was torn about whether it should count because the intent was regular beer, however your shot was nice and frosty, which did meet half the requirement, at least, and it was a beer. Decisions, decisions.
DH, btw, says no (even though he has pleasant memories of root beer from Dog n Suds); I say yes. So yes it is. (Next year I'm hiring an independent judge!)I would be interested to hear what others are thinking here. I just hope you can all appreciate the difficulty of trying to be fair here. (I know you can, you've been a great group!)
tazdev: debate about your locomotive, also.
Will not be able to allow it as we have to see a train that holds freight, sorry. Stargazer: boiling tomatoes, not seeing the sizzle, lol. Show us something else - in the frying pan or on the grill, etc.
funkychunkymonkey - I am unsure if your cow is a Holstein in #815 - can anyone verify?
dizneydaz - #837 Celebration of Independence - please show something 4th of July related (I know you said it was your way of celebrating, but that could have been anywhere, any day, etc). Rollercoaster - that was taken from the top, I believe, then it counts. Unusual mirror, sorry, no - the mirror itself needs to be unusual or ornate. #842 Please explain the Win. Also Kite - is the name of the ride the Kite? (I was looking more for a handheld kite.) Great job finding an ox bow, I didn't know if anyone would get that!
(BTW, is your DH from around the Lafayette area??)
At first he misunderstood when my sister said we were on a scavenger hunt - he thought we wanted THE weathervane!