PEEPS! Fresh or Stale???

[MrsJackSparrow]

STALE!!! They stale quite nicely opened and refrigerated!

 

[UrsulasMyHero]

I will eat them in ANY condition, but I prefer them STALE.

 

[OK!]

I've never liked Peeps in any form. Hate Cadbury Marshmallow Creme Eggs, too. Gimme a basket full of black jellybeans & I'm a happy girl.

 

[Quasi123]

I like them fresh.

 

[Tomader]

I like them stale.

 

[Nancy]

I answered I'll eat em in any condition but I really prefer them stale. It's just that usually I can't wait for them to get stale!

I've been eating Peeps for about 1 month already and I plan on buying a large amount tomorrow so they hold me over a bit.

 

[Cantw8]

I know mine is an unpopular answer but I can't stand peeps I find them nasty and vile little creatures that I would rather see stuck to the bottom of my shoe

 

[tluvstink]

I like them both ways...no let me change that to I love them

Terri

 

[MinnieM21]

Stale but I like them fresh too.

 

[Glynis]

A friend's family likes to make what they call "dead peep on a cracker".

It all started when they wanted to do s'mores and couldn't find any marshmallows - all they had were some stale peeps left over from Easter. So one girl decided to give this a try, so she put a graham cracker square on a plate, added a few pieces of chocolate, and then perched the stale peep on top. She then microwaved this for a few seconds, and apparently the peep swelled up a bit, then deflated as it melted, creating a lot of hilarity for all the kids watching the show. The youngest girl screamed "you killed the peep!" and the only boy in the family promptly named this "dead peep on a cracker". It's now a family tradition to eat "dead peep on a cracker" at Easter...

yes, yes, yes!!!!! This is the only way to eat them!!!!!

 

[Judy from Boise]

I open mine to air for 2 weeks, I usually have 3 boxes in rotation so i never run out of stale peeps!

 

[Disneyanajc]

Fresh Peeps....

 

[Diane]

I think they're really cute and I like to look at them in the store, but I would never eat one! I'm just not a marshmallow lover.

 

[FutureMrsC]

I like microwaved ones... but DH likes them in any form...

OT... circus peanuts are fun microwaved too... they get HUGE!

 

[mallcat]

Nicely aged and sometimes cold.