In our recent experiences at PBH (August and earlier this month), they have outright refused our request to be in the west wing (which is where we have been able to stay during previous club level stays). We have been told that club level guests must stay in the villas section -- building 2.
This is severely limiting the availability of rooms with bay views and/or balconies as well as the opportunities for upgrades for club level guests.
They told me the reason for the new rule is that they want club level guests to have the feeling of staying in something of a private club house, which is why they are confining club level guests to building 2.
I am guessing, although I have not been told this, that the real reason is they were having some difficulty controlling access to the club level lounge when club level guests were coming from all areas of the hotel. With all club level guests confined to building 2, I suspect they think it cuts down on the temptation of guests staying in other buildings to follow club level guests on their way to the lounge and walk in with them. But, this is only my guess.
Due to the rule that club level guests must be in building 2, we have considered not booking club level going forward. But, we enjoy the lounge offerings, which are quite nice (except the desserts later in the evening which are skimpy).
We are not sure what we will do going forward.