mom2rtk
Invented the term "Characterpalooza"
- Joined
- Aug 23, 2008
I think everyone in this thread is either forgetting, drastically underestimating, or ignoring some of the benefits and value to saying on site. I'm not saying that it is worth it, that is a personal decision for each of us, but to imply you aren't getting anything for the extra cost just isn't true. I know this because my upcoming trip is offsite for the time in many years do to the group size and economics, and trust me even though I haven't left yet, I am noticing the difference.
Transportation: Yes, everyone can use Disney transportation, but only onsite guests can use exclusively Disney transportation. The Magical Express will get you to your resort, and a fleet of buses, boats, monorails, (and soon gondolas) will take you anywhere else you need to go.
I live in Ohio, and we fly to MCO. To stay offsite we need to rent a car (approx $360 for my family for 7 nights 8 days) + Gas (approx $60) Parking for 7 days at the parks ($140) And yes, dealing with Disney transportation might at times be annoying, but 99% of the time, it is quicker and simpler than dealing with Theme Park Parking, traffic, and time to get to or from the parks.
That is $560 ($80 a night) and who knows how much time saved by being on site
Extra Magic Hours: It is hard to quantify the dollar value of of this perk. This might as well be 2 extra FP+, or perhaps we should compare it to the paid extra hours... I suppose the simplest way is to count it as free theme park hours and use ticket prices to determine the value. If you take the price of a 4 day non-hopper ticket at $87.50 a day and divide that by an average 12 hour day you get about $7 an hour in value. EMH hours average 1.3 hours per day. That means you get about $9 in value per day per person. That means a family of four on property for 7 nights get $288 in free park hours total or ($40 a night)
Resort Fees: As of today, Disney still doesn't charge a resort fee which most if not all other Orlando area hotels and resorts charge. These range from $3 a night to over $60 a night. Well use $15 a night for a stay at someplace that might be comparable in some ways to a WDW value resort.
Magic Bands: I know, many of us really don't care about these, but the truth is they are a perk and have a value of around $20.
Those items alone apply to all WDW resorts and have a savings or value of $155 a night. That is more than the actual rack rate on some value resorts. If you subtract that from the rack rate of a deluxe, it puts Deluxe resorts starting around $220 a night (or a $110 if you go during a time when they offer 30% off)
This doesn't even take into account the difference in level of themeing, convenience, and service you get onsite when compared to offsite. People can complain all they want about Disney slipping in any of those areas, but I think when people compare Disney to the competition, instead of Disney to itself 10 years ago, Disney is still well above the others.
And anyone who wants to either eat at a popular table service restaurant, or book a FP+ for the top attraction at each park can tell you that onsite booking advantages mean something.
I fell in love with Disney during my first onsite stay (my honeymoon). If you are here on these boards, I think most of you had a similar experience, and I would bet the majority of them were while staying on site.
I don't think anyone is drastically underestimating anything. It's just that different people value different things differently. What's important to you might not be important to someone else. Nobody is saying there's no value to staying onsite. It's just a matter of it holding a different value for everyone.
We typically stay onsite. But if we could stay offsite for twice as long for the same price as some have reported? I might consider it.
Some prefer to have a car regardless of what transportation is available.
Resort fees don't matter if your offsite room is quite a bit less to begin with.
Some people avoid EMH like the plague anyway.