Thanks to all for the comments and suggestions. We tried a few of the “softer” options: lights on, sleeping at the foot of the bed, staying with her until she fell asleep. However, the more of these things we tried, the more it felt like it was a game she was playing to see what she could get away with (she is at a very manipulative stage). I suspect, if we let her sleep in bed with us, there would be some other “perk” she would push for next. After a couple of exasperating nights, we decided to try some “tough love”. We told her she had to sleep in her own bed (we did provide some comforting words), then offered to leave the hall light on with the door open, we promised to check on her every few minutes and left the room. She screamed for a couple of minutes. Then we went back in and calmed her down (again, there was not a sense of true panic in her, so we were a little suspicious) and this time we told her if she didn’t calm down we would take away one of her stuffed animals. We again left the room. She wimpered for about 15 seconds. Within 5 minutes she was out cold. She woke up crying during the night. We took her to the bathroom and then put her back in bed. She again protested that she didn’t want to sleep alone, but we just laid her down and she went right back to sleep. The last couple of nights have gotten progressively easier. She is still fusing a little and waking, but less frequently and with very little crying.
We tried to be the good cops, but sometimes I guess you need to be the bad cop to get results.
Thanks, again to all.
Eric