Opinions please: BW Hacienda Old Town or BW Island Palms?

[Lisa S.]

I need opinions on BW Old Town and BW Island Palms. Both look good, and I've heard great reviews about Island Palms, but I'm concerned about the ease of getting around while staying there. All info appreciated!

 

[blabbermouth]

We stayed at Island Palms in 2009 and really liked it. It was a nice setting being on the island/pier. However, we did have a car, and I think it might be a pain to get around without one. San Diego is pretty spread out though so you might want a car anyway.

 

[lcasa]

Never stayed at that Old Town BW but seen it many times - while we're trying to park in that area, since there are many good restaurants and things to do right there.
It looks pretty nice - very hacienda-like.

 

[Lisa S.]

We stayed at Island Palms in 2009 and really liked it. It was a nice setting being on the island/pier. However, we did have a car, and I think it might be a pain to get around without one. San Diego is pretty spread out though so you might want a car anyway.

Thanks for the reply. We're going to have a car, so I think this may work for us.

Never stayed at that Old Town BW but seen it many times - while we're trying to park in that area, since there are many good restaurants and things to do right there.
It looks pretty nice - very hacienda-like.

Thanks for the input!