Opinions on this commentary?

dadtoagirl

Slowly being driven broke by two women!
Joined
Jun 29, 2005
Messages
394
Masques of Death

By George Neumayr

Published 9/2/2005 12:12:28 AM

New Orleans has one of the highest murder rates in the country. By mid-August of this year, 192 murders had been committed in New Orleans, "nearly 10 times the national average," reported the Associated Press. Gunfire is so common in New Orleans -- and criminals so fierce -- that when university researchers conducted an experiment last year in which they had cops fire 700 blank rounds in a neighborhood on a random afternoon "no one called to report the gunfire," reported AP.

New Orleans was ripe for collapse. Its dangerous geography, combined with a dangerous culture, made it susceptible to an unfolding catastrophe. Currents of chaos and lawlessness were running through the city long before this week, and they were bound to come to the surface under the pressure of natural disaster and explode in a scene of looting and mayhem.

Like riotous Los Angeles since the 1960s, New Orleans has been a wasteland of politically correct dysfunction for decades -- public schools so obviously decimated vouchers were proposed this year (and torpedoed by the left), barbaric gangster rap culture no one will confront lest they offend liberal pieties, multiculturalist frauds who empower no one but themselves, and cops neutered by the NAACP and ACLU.

Criminals have ruled New Orleans for some time, convincing many members of the middle class, long before the hurricane, that the city was unlivable. In 1994, New Orleans was the murder capital of America. It had 421 murders that year. Criminologists predicted 300 murders this year, a projection that now looks quite conservative.

Criminals dominate their neighborhoods to the point that people don't even call in crimes. The district attorney's office, tacitly admitting that the city's law-abiding citizens live in fear, has taken the "unusual" step of establishing a local witness protection program to encourage the reporting of crime, reports AP.

According to the New Orleans Police Foundation, most murderers get off -- only 1 in 4 are convicted -- and 42 percent of cases involving serious crimes since 2002 have been dropped by prosecutors.

Meanwhile, cops, when they can get away with it, have been living out of town. It is far too scary for them and their families. New Orleans Police officers are required to live in the city but many ignore this residency requirement, according to the Times-Picayune. The paper discovered that many top-ranking New Orleands cops lived in the suburbs and that most cops, both black and white, wanted the residency requirement rescinded.

For reasons of political correctness -- critics of law enforcement say lifting the residency requirement will mean more white cops eager to brutalize residents of the inner city and fewer black cops understanding of them -- the residency requirement remains, though cops breaking the rule told the Times-Picayune that it seriously hurts recruitment. It also -- this is particularly evident in Los Angeles where cops involved in the Ramparts scandal turned out to be ex-criminals -- distorts recruitment.

If the New Orleans Police Department has appeared feeble during the chaos -- and in some cases complicit in it -- policies like the residency requirement explain the breakdown. (Perhaps another factor that has rendered the NOPD feckless in the face of a rising murder rate is the criticism of its handling of a minority Mardi Gras.) Americans who have seen cops join in the looting ask: Why are police officers behaving like criminals? Well, because PC police departments like the NOPD hire them. Aggressive, let's-just-meet-the-quota-style affirmative action has become the door through which criminals enter the police academy.

More than the physical foundations of New Orleans will need to be rebuilt over the next few years. Its politically correct culture in which pathologies are allowed to fester in the name of "progress" forms much of the debris that must be cleared away if civilization is to return to New Orleans. A city which boasts as one of its businesses memorial "death t-shirts" -- clothing made popular by the frequency of gangland slayings in New Orleans that say things like, "Born a Pimp, Died a Playa" -- was headed for collapse even without a hurricane, and had become, as the exodus of cops illustrates, unlivable.

Conservative black leaders have been mau-maued into silence whenever they tell the truth about this barbarism and call for dramatic reform. But they are the ones who must lead the city now, and the phonies at organizations like the NAACP who despite all their rhetoric haven't done a thing to help the black underclass should step aside. Hurricane Katrina has made vivid the civilizational collapse they have long tried to conceal.

George Neumayr is executive editor of The American Spectator
 
There is a lot of truth in the commentary, albeit, politically incorrect. It is no wonder that the powder keg exploded when ignited. It was volitile to begin with.
 
DawnCt1 said:
It is no wonder that the powder keg exploded when ignited. It was volitile to begin with.
I was just thinking the same thing. :sad2:
 
Just more of let's blame the victims. Partisan politics at its worst.
 

My opinion on the commentary? I'm sure there's an element of truth to it, as there's an element to it that can be applied to all major cities.
However I think it's a blatant example of the blame the victim because it's easier to do that than actually figure out what went wrong and fix it game.
 
swilphil said:
Just more of let's blame the victims. Partisan politics at its worst.

Many of the victims were victimized by their own citizens. They have been victimized for years by a criminal element that largely has gone unchecked. How much additional help could have gotton into New Orleans if the rescue choppers, ambulances, police, national guard weren't being fired on? The inner parts of New Orleans have been allowed to slip into decedance because it was easier than confronting the problem. In parts of that city, more than 50% of the citizens are on welfare. What kind of compassion is that? If we all deserve to live in clean, crime free neighborhoods, what did the local and state governments do to clean it up, long before there was a Hurricane Katrina?
 
New Orleans was ripe for collapse. Its dangerous geography, combined with a dangerous culture, made it susceptible to an unfolding catastrophe. Currents of chaos and lawlessness were running through the city long before this week, and they were bound to come to the surface under the pressure of natural disaster and explode in a scene of looting and mayhem.

Geez....and I guess it's all their fault that a hurricane hit and they didn't get out in time either.

Total, complete and utter crap. And you can quote me on it.
 
We must also begin to address the conditions that create crime.
Nothing happens in a vacuum.
 
Article of fact. It is not blaming the victims. Any blame should be put on incompetent corrupt state and local officials since the Huey Long era!! The truth is that even on a normal day, New Orleans is a sad city. Sure, tourists think New Orleans is fun: you can drink and hop from strip club to strip club all night on Bourbon Street, and gamble all your money away at Harrah’s. But the city’s decline over the past decades has left it impoverished and lacking the leadership to build its economy from within.
 
Well, I'm no pro on the NO area, so I can only take anything I see in one article on face value. If things were that bad there, it's very sad that the people of NO were forced to live in that type of fear. I don't blame the majority of the population as I'm sure they're mostly law abiding citizens, but the criminal element needs to be address and corrected. I can't even imagine having to live in fear of reporting any crime I might be witness to. I'll never give a criminal a free pass, NEVER! To me, this is just another failure on our government's part (local government in this case) to protect the citizens of this country. It ain't only happening in NO either and that's even more sad.
 
The Mayor of NO as well as the NO Chief of Police, say the Looting (I like to just call it Robbing or Stealing), started well in advance of the Hurricane. It was like Christmas to the Criminals who control that city, when the Mayor called the evacuation. They, meaning the police, were having to deal with the Looting Thugs instead of evacuating the helpless residents of NO prior to the approaching Hurricane. After the hurricane, and during the flood, the looting just got worse and more widespread, and when the first TV camera was on the scene, the Looting thug somehow became the "desperate man just feeding his family". I wonder how many NIKE shoes it takes to feed a family?
 
swilphil said:
Just more of let's blame the victims. Partisan politics at its worst.


OK, I've read the commentary three times now, and I still can't a single example of blaming the victim. It doesn't even talk about the hurricane and its aftermath, except in passing.

It talks about political correctness, liberal politicians, criminals, crime stats and schools that suck. But where is the "blame the victim" that you are seeing?

I'm seriously wondering, because I just don't see it.
 
gina2000 said:
Geez....and I guess it's all their fault that a hurricane hit and they didn't get out in time either.

Total, complete and utter crap. And you can quote me on it.

And again, where is the author saying that it was their fault that the hurricane hit? He's simply saying that when a city is already apparently falling apart, it doesn't take much of a disaster to push it over the edge.
 
Just another right wing extremist ranting and raving and trying to blame all the evils of the world on liberals....what's new?
 
peachgirl said:
Just another right wing extremist ranting and raving and trying to blame all the evils of the world on liberals....what's new?

You're right. I haven't seen any liberals blaming the evils of the world on conservatives.

:rotfl:

I think it's funny to watch liberals and conservatives fight. It's like watching two snakes argue over who has sexier legs.
 
BuckNaked said:
And again, where is the author saying that it was their fault that the hurricane hit? He's simply saying that when a city is already apparently falling apart, it doesn't take much of a disaster to push it over the edge.

What she said!
 
peachgirl said:
Just another right wing extremist ranting and raving and trying to blame all the evils of the world on liberals....what's new?

Pardon me, Extremist??? Peachgirl calm down a bit!!
 
Jaybrad said:
Pardon me, Estremist??? Peachgirl calm down a bit!!

No, eXtremist...:rotfl2:

I'm fine, but with all those ? marks and !!!'s you do seem to be a bit worked up yourself.

I suggest a margarita...Michael Brown seems to think they'll do the trick..:teeth:
 
peachgirl said:
No, eXtremist...:rotfl2:

I'm fine, but with all those ? marks and !!!'s you do seem to be a bit worked up yourself.

I suggest a margarita...Michael Brown seems to think they'll do the trick..:teeth:


Nothing wrong with a Margarita! We have a new one locally it is Mango. Pretty good stuff.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom