OMG! Trading Le Cellier for Shula's or Yachtsman

[RachaelRol]

Oh and we will definitely have the apple pie for dessert!

 

[DonaldDoleWhip]

I have to tell you- Your reviews of the new Le Cellier menu is what made me want to try the non-steak choices. Everything looked so great!

I'm glad you liked the review - it surprises me that most of the dinner feedback here has been so negative. I was amazed by the improvement since my last few lunches here.

That said, it sounds like Shula's is the place to go for a good steak. The menu looks very similar to Ruth's Chris, so I don't have a huge desire to go (filet is basically the only steak I like anyway - I prefer to stick with the non-steak choices). But I'm sure all the food there is good.

 

[RachaelRol]

I'm glad you liked the review - it surprises me that most of the dinner feedback here has been so negative. I was amazed by the improvement since my last few lunches here.

That said, it sounds like Shula's is the place to go for a good steak. The menu looks very similar to Ruth's Chris, so I don't have a huge desire to go (filet is basically the only steak I like anyway - I prefer to stick with the non-steak choices). But I'm sure all the food there is good.

Funny- I don't like Ruth Chris.... I hope Shula's is better than that...

Maybe booking LCs for lunch is a good option. I'm going to check out the menu. I think that will allow us to try the new options.

ETA:Just checked lunch menu- none of the new thinkgs I'd like to try are listed on the Disney World website.... boo

 

[goofyintoronto]

So glad to hear we're not the only ones. One meal at Le Cellier - dh and I looked at each other and said "Really? This is what all the hype is about?? "

I honestly thought the same thing you did. As i took a spoonful of soup and a bite of bread, i thought "what the heck? Really?". I couldnt understand the the hype. But I held out hope for the steak....i so wanted to love the steak. But sadly, i didnt love it. I cant say i liked it either. I was very disapointed. I wont be back anytime soon.

It seems as fashionable to bash le Cellier nowadays as it was to praise it just a few months back. Personally, I've had both the old and new menus and loed it both times, but myself and my kids are all steak eaters.

Not me, I was and have been a Le Cellier basher when being a Le Cellier basher was not cool on the DIS and was considered blasphemy, almost worthy of being shunned.


In my opinion, as a huge steak lover, I thought it was a rather average experience at best. As for opinions, I guess they are like belly buttons and booty's, we all have one and they are all different.

>>>OMG this post made me laugh sooo hard. bahahaha. Your hilarious!!!