I think this was my favorite meal from our recent trip. We didn't have a PS and got in for lunch without any wait. I've read this is the place WDW CMs go for a meal and I understand why. Our server was friendly, attentive and knowledgable. I had the grilled cheese soup and the crab cake appetizer for my meal...wanted dessert - the mango pie. It was tasty, but I wished I had another bowl of that soup! It was fantastic! If you do like to indulge in an alcoholic beverage, try the Sulty Seahorse...little sweet and a little tart, but tasty!
My DH is interested in the menu at Oliva's (Old Key West). I checked out the reader reviews on allears and there is only one review (positive) but it's not enough to go on. We are already booked at CRT, Chef Mickey's for Breakfast and Dinner at Boma, Cafe May, Coral Reef, Ohana's, 1900 Park Fare and Mama Melrose (which I and my 2 DD's chose). My Dh wanted to go here but I wanted to make sure it was worth it. Any thoughts would be appreciated!! 
