We liked Spoodles but it didn't wow us. The dips and Sangria were very good, DH liked his steak but my entree was blech...desserts were good. the dish is not on the menu any longer...it was the mediteranian stew...loaded with anise...yuck! It is also pretty loud in there.
We did Olivia's once for lunch and once for dinner. We liked it both times. Burgers were good, DH liked his steak and I had the pasta with shrimp. It was yummy.
If I had to choose, I would go to Olivia's.