Just got home from OKW last week. do not eat at Olivia's for anything other than breakfast unless you love salty food. everything we ordered was way to salty! same at Vero. same flavors too. we got our meals refunded at both places. First two times I have ever asked for a refund since we started going 3-7 times a year in 1996.
Old key west is quiet, clean, and beautiful. important to remember it has no elevators! If you have issues with stairs ( and lots of them), ask for ground floor!