We are going in a few weeks with eyes wide open! As a group, we don't spend tons of time in the GCH...we spend more time in our room relaxing on the balcony, and I hope our room requests (which would put us on the GF side of the Poly complex) work out. Also as a group going without kids this trip, we won't use the pool.
When the group I'm going with decided on where to stay, we chose the Poly because:
1. We like the theme and the updated rooms...and as it's a short trip, and we won't use much of the overall resort this time.
2. We LOVE the location, with the boat and monorail to the MK and a walk to the monorail to Epcot.
3. We looked into other deluxes with good transportation to parks, as that was one of our main desires for this trip. And after considering CR, GF, WL, BC/YC, we went with Poly because...CR and GF were priced so much higher (even with fall discounts), and as we won't really use the resort amenities (like a pool), the extra cost wasn't worth it. WL just doesn't appeal to us thematically, though it was cheaper. BC/YC (which I LOVE when I'm traveling with kids) was a similar price to Poly...but we liked the Poly theme better, even knowing there would be construction.
4. It was close between BC/YC and Poly...but as we'll spend more time in our room/balcony, we went with Poly because their rooms have been more recently updated. And because Poly offers quick transport to our two favorite parks, MK and Epcot.
So there you have it.
And I can't wait until I'm there again! Was at the poly almost 10 years ago, and I LOVED it (and didn't use the pool or GCH much then either). I am really looking forward to this trip.
