Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

[Virgo10]

While I'm glad that Mikalah is gone I have to say she handled herself with class and dignity when she got the news.

I wasn't surprised that Nadia was in the bottom 3. I don't know what others are doing but I'm basing my vote on their performance for the current week. This was a weak week for her

Now it really gets difficult because there's something good about all the people who are left. My guess is that without a knock your socks off performance Nikko, Vonzell or Anthony will be the next to go. Maybe even Anwar or Jessica. Who knows? The only consistent one of the group is Bo! (IMHO)

As for Scott, well if the Idol On Fox site is any indication, he has a huge fan base.

 

[Tasha+Scott]

All I can say is last night was the best AI I have ever watched...and that is b/c Mikalah if FINALLY gone!!!

The bottom 3 did not surprise me at all. I was predicting that it would come down to Nadia, Mikalah, and Anthony. I like Nadia but based on this week's performances she was definitely one of the weakest. And honestly, I don't think the hairstyle helped any! But I was surprised she was in the bottom 2. I thought the bottom 2 would be between Anthony and Mikalah w/Mikalah being the one to go. But who cares as long as Mikalah's finally gone! And this is a great top 10...so glad Mikalah won't be going on tour!

I also agree with whoever said they think Scott has a stronger fanbase than people think. I think week after week he ends up with new fans. I worry about Nikko b/c I am not sure about his fanbase but I love him and was thrilled when they brought him back. If they hadn't divided the guys and girls evenly I doubt he would have ever gone to begin with. It would have probably been one of the girls that got the boot. My faves this week were Vonzell, Nikko, Bo, Scott, and Carrie, and not necessarily in that order. I am hoping Nadia will do better next week b/c she is so talented.

My prediction for who will be gone next week is Anthony...unless he does something to blow everyone away. At this stage in the competition he is going to have to step it up. He is starting to become forgettable...at least to me!

 

[aengus]

DING DONG The witch is dead! WOHOO! did I ever mention that I hated that Mikalah girl?


Who's next? I gotta think anthony or nikko.

props to Jessica and Carrie this week, they really did out sing all the guys who I used to think were a lock for the whole thing. GAME ON!

 

[StaceyA]

Again last night after they said each one was safe they showed the friends and family in the audience....but for Scott they just panned a random section....that stinks for him....at least he has fans out there suporting him!

 

[GoofieRuthie]

I must be the only person that CAN'T STAND Constantine. I kind of liked his rendition of "I Think I Love You", but I can't stand to watch him. I really hope he goes soon. I think he is on a major ego trip and don't see what everyone else does in him. I hate how they keep pitting him and Bo against each other as "The Rockers" too. Bo, is TRULY talented. I could watch and listen to him all day. My top three pics are Bo, Carrie, and Jessica.

I am so glad that Mikalah is gone now. I couldn't stand how her nasally voice came through in her singing. She had a very powerful singing voice if she could just get rid of the nasal. When she was talking last night I kept thinking she sounded just like The Nanny. ugh The rest of the season should be interesting now.

 

[Gymbomom]

I must be the only person that CAN'T STAND Constantine. I kind of liked his rendition of "I Think I Love You", but I can't stand to watch him. I really hope he goes soon. I think he is on a major ego trip and don't see what everyone else does in him. I hate how they keep pitting him and Bo against each other as "The Rockers" too. Bo, is TRULY talented. I could watch and listen to him all day. My top three pics are Bo, Carrie, and Jessica.

I am so glad that Mikalah is gone now. I couldn't stand how her nasally voice came through in her singing. She had a very powerful singing voice if she could just get rid of the nasal. When she was talking last night I kept thinking she sounded just like The Nanny. ugh The rest of the season should be interesting now.

I grew up in the 80's and remember the hair bands and heavy metal rocker bands.
I wasn't really into all that and when girls would talk about the rockers, that they were so HOT, I would always think, gross!
Well Constantine reminds me of one of those rockers. LOL
He looks into the camera and he just gives me the creeps.
Although he did really good this past week!

 

[Obi-Wan Pinobi]

It's all our fault.

Every week we always end up voting for Constantine, Bo, Nadia and Anthony.

This week we voted for Constantine, Bo, Carrie and Jessica and BOOM. Nadia and Anthony are in the bottom 3.

Oh the shame.

 

[Mickeyfaniam]

I'm another one..... I can't stand Constantine either....he gives me the creeps too with his facial expressions
I hope he's gone next week .... and
I'm glad Makayla was gone.

Anthony is too talented to be gone this soon but I think hitting the bottom 3 might do him some good. He needed to be brought done a peg or too. May work the same way for Nadia. I can't stand it when their heads get so big.

One of the reasons I always loved Clay Aiken so much ....... he wasn't like that at all

 

[sweet angel]

I must be the only person that CAN'T STAND Constantine. I kind of liked his rendition of "I Think I Love You", but I can't stand to watch him. I really hope he goes soon. I think he is on a major ego trip and don't see what everyone else does in him. I hate how they keep pitting him and Bo against each other as "The Rockers" too. Bo, is TRULY talented.

You might be interested to know that Constantine was trained at the Boston Conservatory of Music and was a member of the touring performance of "Rent".

 

[Gymbomom]

I really think Constantine has talent, he just is creepy. Did you notice on Wednesday as they replayed, he would just look into the camera.....even when Seacrest was talking to him.

 

[sweet angel]

I really think Constantine has talent, he just is creepy. Did you notice on Wednesday as they replayed, he would just look into the camera.....even when Seacrest was talking to him.

Nope, but I loooooooooooooooooove him, so it wouldn't bother me. And for those who comment on the teeny bopper fan base...I'm 39.

 

[christinadei]

I'm another one who's relieved to see Mikalya gone. I think she's cute though and has a great attitude. She's annoying yeah, but she reminds me of the Nanny, who I used to love. I think Mikalya should be an actress or model. Preferably a model so no one has to hear her talk, lol, but she's got the personality of an actress.

I used to like Constantine a lot, but he's starting to creep me out too, I hate all those "cute" expressions he always does like he thinks he's really hot, because I don't think he is, but I"ve always been a fan.

Am I the only one who can't stand Bo? I swear he can't get a bad comment from anyone, judges or otherwise. I can't stand him and i think he has no talent at all. I think Constantine has way more talent than he does. I know I'm in the minority, so no flaming please.

Anyway, I think that the bottom three were right, I knew it would be Mikalya and Anthony and I really like Nadia, but based on last weeks performance, she should've been #3. I think Anthony will go next.

I love Scott and think he has mad talent. He gets better and better every week. I didn't like him at first because of his attitude, but it seems to have gotten better, and his lack of support, makes me want to support him more.

My top pick is still Carrie. This is such a tough season, there is so much talent. After Anthony goes, I'll be so sad every week to lose someone.

 

[Gymbomom]

I think Mikalya should be an actress or model. Preferably a model so no one has to hear her talk, lol, but she's got the personality of an actress.

 

[cadburysmom]

Darn, I missed Wednesday night's show as well as last night's show but I think it was time for Mikayla to go....just too darn nasally, IMHO.

And although I agree with Simon that Carrie will win...and out of all the contestants, I would DEFINITELY buy a CD by Bo. His rendition of "Time in a Bottle" gave me goosebumps...he DEFINITELY does a great job of picking the right song.

And yes, I'm a big Constantine fan too....never would've believed he'd pick "I Think I Love You" but I absolutely LOVED his rendition....way to go Constantine!

 

[Tasha+Scott]

I must be the only person that CAN'T STAND Constantine. I kind of liked his rendition of "I Think I Love You", but I can't stand to watch him. I really hope he goes soon.

Nope, you are not alone. I have not liked Constantine from the very beginning. I remember watching his audition and he sang an Aerosmith song. Dh and I thought he completely butchered the song and were waiting for the judges to say so, but they ended up loving him and so do so many people on this thread. I never got the attraction, but then I never got the attraction of Anwar either, so I am in the minority. And yes, I already knew about Constantine being in Rent, etc., etc. It doesn't change my opinion. But then, I like Nikko and Scott and I know a lot of others don't like them, so to each his own.

Oh, but out of all of the songs that Constantine has sang, I did like his rendition of "I Think I Love You" the best...even though he still didn't wow me.

 

[disneyworldgirl]

I really think Constantine has talent, he just is creepy. Did you notice on Wednesday as they replayed, he would just look into the camera.....even when Seacrest was talking to him.

I noticed that Carrie does the same thing when she sings. Her eyes just follow the camera lens. They're both great vocally, but I think they need to forget about the camera. It does look a little "creepy" after awhile.

I have to say that Mikalah surprised me with her professionalism after she was voted off (though I was getting really tired of her saying "fabulous" during the retrospective). I'm glad she took it as well as she did. I was a bit surprised to see Nadia in the "Bottom 3", and my heart almost went through the floor when Ryan called Anthony onto the stage!

BTW, has anyone else here noticed that Simon seems to favor the pretty, blond, female performers (even when they're not the best of the night)? Or am I just imagining things? Anyway, it's really starting to get on my nerves.

Also, I read that Paula is being accused of a hit-and-run. From what I read, she allegedly bumped into someone's car a few nights ago. Nobody was hurt (that I know of), but one of the other car's passengers took a picture of her car and license plate number with a camera-phone (I think that's what you call them), and the police traced it back to her. She said her car was in the shop at the time of the accident, but they found out it wasn't taken in for repairs until the following day. Does anybody think this might be connected to her behavior recently? I like Paula, but she's been acting a little bizarre lately.

 

[Jennasis]

Just curoius...how many of you would be so "candid" with your analysis of the performers if you knew they were reading the boards...or better yet, to their face? I just can't help but think how awful it would make me feel to read about how total strangers "Hate" me or think I'm "creepy" etc.

Sigh.


I love AI. I predict that it will come down to Carrie and Bo. I definitely think they should do a duet. Has anyone else notice how those two are around each other? I always see Bo looking at her and occassionally had his arm around her.

 

[minniepumpernickel]

Just curoius...how many of you would be so "candid" with your analysis of the performers if you knew they were reading the boards...or better yet, to their face? I just can't help but think how awful it would make me feel to read about how total strangers "Hate" me or think I'm "creepy" etc.

Sigh.


I love AI. I predict that it will come down to Carrie and Bo. I definitely think they should do a duet. Has anyone else notice how those two are around each other? I always see Bo looking at her and occassionally had his arm around her.

Yes, but they are public figures now. I guess that is part of the process when you becoma a "star".

I don't see Carrie and Bo togethor. I think that they probably have other people in their lives. Bo also hugged Mikahla. I'm sure that it was just a nice gesture.

I was suprised to see Nadia in the bottom three. Maybe it was the mohawk? I was also suprised about Anwar too. Oh well, atleast Mikahla is gone!

 

[Gymbomom]

Just curoius...how many of you would be so "candid" with your analysis of the performers if you knew they were reading the boards...or better yet, to their face? I just can't help but think how awful it would make me feel to read about how total strangers "Hate" me or think I'm "creepy" etc.

Sigh.


I love AI. I predict that it will come down to Carrie and Bo. I definitely think they should do a duet. Has anyone else notice how those two are around each other? I always see Bo looking at her and occassionally had his arm around her.

Hmmmm, isn't the show about people voting about the performers based on their opinions about these performers? And isn't this thread about talking and voicing our opinions about this subject???
No, to anwser your question I would never go up to Constatine and tell him I thought he was creepy, but I would tell him that he rocked when he sang on Tuesday night!
I mean, he can sing a whole better than me and has gotten far in this competition!

 

[disneyworldgirl]

I probably wouldn't use the word "creepy", but I would tell both Constantine and Carrie that they need to connect to the live audience more, and forget about the camera.

I don't think I'd say anything different to any of the contestants than I say on the thread. I try to be diplomatic about things, but I have to be honest as well.