Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think the best last night were Carrie and Jessica. I also really liked Anthony, Bo and Constantine.

And I don't care what anyone says, I still like Mikalah. I honestly don't think she did as bad as everyone thought she did last night. I thought the beginning was a little shaky, but after that I thought it was good. I'm still voting for her, and I don't think she'll be the one going home because she was already in the bottom 2 last week, and I think some of her fans are going to go crazy voting for her.

I also thought Vonzell did good, but I don't think she has a very strong fan base. I wouldn't be surprised if she's in the bottom tomorrow.

As for Anwar and Nadia, I predict them to be in the top 4, but not if they coninue to sing like they did yesterday. They both weren't that good. They're both usually good, but they're not my favorites. If it were up to me I would pick different people to be in the top 4, but I think they will be there. And as for the hair, I don't know how she wasn't embarrassed. When I saw Carrie's hair, all I could say was "yuck". But after seeing Nadia's, I just completely forgot about Carrie's hairdo. She really has to get rid of the hair.

The last two are Nikko and Scott. I never liked them and I definitely didn't like them last night. I will be so mad if Nikko makes it to the top 10, and someone else I like goes home tomorrow. There were 6 peole I really liked that made it to the top 12, and 1 of them went home last week. If Nikko stays around, he'll be going on tour, and one of my favorites will be going home, leaving only 4 of them to be on tour. I wanted Nikko and Scott to be the first two to leave, but if one of them goes home tomorrow I will be happy. I doubt that's gonna happen though.
 
orangeblossom said:
I don't think she really has the right look to model.

I assume you are speaking of Mikalah?
Think of it this way.... in modeling, she wouldn't have to speak or sing!
 

ShuisFan584 said:
I think the best last night were Carrie and Jessica. I also really liked Anthony, Bo and Constantine.

And I don't care what anyone says, I still like Mikalah. I honestly don't think she did as bad as everyone thought she did last night. I thought the beginning was a little shaky, but after that I thought it was good. I'm still voting for her, and I don't think she'll be the one going home because she was already in the bottom 2 last week, and I think some of her fans are going to go crazy voting for her.

I also thought Vonzell did good, but I don't think she has a very strong fan base. I wouldn't be surprised if she's in the bottom tomorrow.

As for Anwar and Nadia, I predict them to be in the top 4, but not if they coninue to sing like they did yesterday. They both weren't that good. They're both usually good, but they're not my favorites. If it were up to me I would pick different people to be in the top 4, but I think they will be there. And as for the hair, I don't know how she wasn't embarrassed. When I saw Carrie's hair, all I could say was "yuck". But after seeing Nadia's, I just completely forgot about Carrie's hairdo. She really has to get rid of the hair.

The last two are Nikko and Scott. I never liked them and I definitely didn't like them last night. I will be so mad if Nikko makes it to the top 10, and someone else I like goes home tomorrow. There were 6 peole I really liked that made it to the top 12, and 1 of them went home last week. If Nikko stays around, he'll be going on tour, and one of my favorites will be going home, leaving only 4 of them to be on tour. I wanted Nikko and Scott to be the first two to leave, but if one of them goes home tomorrow I will be happy. I doubt that's gonna happen though.


Then she's good for at 7 or 8 votes! :teeth:
 
:earseek: appearantly the phone numbers for voting last night were displayed incorrectly for anwar, mikaylah, and jessica, and there is going to be a revote tonight?!?!
fine with me, as after 90 minutes of off and on trying i wasn't able to get through for anyone. i don't get it though, will tonight's episode air tomorrow then? what will air tonight? :confused:
full story here:
http://www.comcast.net/entertainment/index.jsp?cat=ENTERTAINMENT&fn=/2005/03/23/88835.html
 
oh nevermind....i just saw someone else posted this already. i'm lame
 
I heard due to the voting error, that the contenstants will have to sing all over again tonight and tomorrow will be the night we find out who gets the boot. What a mess!!! :confused3

Also what was up with Paula & Simon? She was all on him last night. Paula was in a very wild mood. Dancing etc....

I hope Mikalah gets the boot next. She did not sound good at all!!! Sorry, but it's time for her to go!!

Disappointed in Nadia. Nadia picked the wrong song. Not for her vocal range.
Did not like the hair either.

Nikko surprised me and did really good this week. I think this was his best performance.

Scott did just ok for me. I've heard him do better.

Carrie- WOW!!! She sang her butt off. She did an excellent job.

Jessica- Another wow. I love that song she sang too. Brings back memories. She did very good. One of her best performances.

Anwar- Seen him do better too. Not sure what made him pick the Chaka Khan song.

Constatine- Wasn't that great of a performance to me. Kind of cheesy.

Bo- did excellent as usual. Good song choice.

Vonzell- did great I thought. Very upbeat. She is a good performer.

I think the bottom 3 should be definitely Mikalah, Anthony & Constastine
 
Someone brought up the text messages being charged for last night's vote mix up. Fox has this on their site:

Text votes sent by Cigular Wireless (and former AT&T Wireless) customers last night will not be charged.
 
I am tuning out because I can't take Mikalah singing Taylor Dayne again - once was more than enough! :earseek:

I dug Constantine's version of "I Think I Love You". I think it's pretty cool that this young guy can, without embarrassment, sing the Partridge Family. Very noble. ;)
 
OK - yesterday I called Bo Bo-ring :rolleyes: I take it back! I admit I was wrong! He was really good! And he just keeps looking finer and finer! :love:
 
I thought Nikko was better when I heard him tonight than I did last night....He's still not my favorite but he wasn't terrible, either.
 
I love Nikko and Bo every single time. :)

But my heart and votes always go to Anwar. :flower:

OK, my votes go to all 3 - I'm fickle. ;)
 
Yuck, Nikko go home! Now I'm even more mad that Randy said he was the best last night. What was he listening to??? :confused3
 
ShuisFan584 said:
Yuck, Nikko go home! Now I'm even more mad that Randy said he was the best last night. What was he listening to??? :confused3

And I love Nikko. I think he sounds all smooth and smoky-sexy. Everyone has their own taste. :)
 
Nadia was even worse watching her the second time, but I really like her. She was just having an off night, IMO. I also think if she doesn't make it all the way on AI then she could do America's Next Top Model. lol
 
Just finished listening to Mikayla again. Oooo Simon is mean! Anyway, she sounded bad but to be fair, I think she has a unique voice and with more training, would make a great singer.

That being said...quit talking...you're not helping yourself!
 
LOL at Mikalah's shirt! :rotfl: I guess she knows that a lot of people don't like her and she was making a joke out of it.

And wow Nadia was bad, I don't remember her being that bad yesterday. I still think she'll be top 4.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.




New Posts









Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE







New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top