Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

[disneyworldgirl]

Will Vonzell get the best of your love? Constantine thinks he loves you, but how much do you love him? Will love lead Mikalah back for another week? Will Jessica be totally eclipsed from the competition?

Okay, I'm done being corny ( ). Time to vote!

 

[sweet angel]

I enjoyed everyone except Mikayla and Anthony. I like Mikayla, but she needs to find a sitcom, not a recording contract. Anthony is just flat out boring. There's nothing appealing about him (and I also had a crush on Donny Osmond as a kid).

Constantine -- who else could've pulled off a Partridge Family song? At the very least, he's going against the grain and picking songs that HE likes -- not necessary the bland, expected stuff. Besides, he does that really cute squinchy thing with his nose when he smiles.

My picks for bottom 2 would be Mikayla and Anthony.

 

[wdwgirl03]

I really liked almost everyone tonight. Except Mikayla. She wasn't that good. I bet it's good bye for her...

 

[Cindy B]

Anwars line has been open and easily accessible for the past hour. Please! We need to keep him in.

Who else noticed that Mikalah didn't talk much?

 

[StaceyA]

Carrie- Whoa big hair 80's flashback.

Ahh those were the days, I loved doing up my bangs...see my tag for more info...LOL

 

[DisneyArk]

Yes, I was glad Mikayla did not talk to much.

I've been wondering how the spoilers were right about what Simon was going to say. Did he really say the same things during the practice? That seems odd to me.

I thought tonight was a good night and I enjoyed hearing most of them! Carrie did great and so did Bo. Too bad that Nadia and Anwar did not have a good night - I didn't like their song choice for their voice/style.

 

[Sandy22]

Ahh those were the days, I loved doing up my bangs...see my tag for more info...LOL

OMG - I LOVED to poof my bangs! Well the whole top of my head actually! Oh, and of course, I poofed out the sides too...really now...I had to keep it all in proportion! Needless to say...I had BIG hair!

 

[julia & nicks mom]

OMG - my DH just read on the Idol boards and we just watched it on our Tivo that they messed up the numbers for Mikayla, Anwar and Jessica

I edited to put the mistake in red

For Mikayla they put call
866-idols-09
866-436-5101

text to 5709

For Anwar they put call
866-idols-10
866-436-5102

text to 5710

For Jessica they put call
866-idols-11
866-436-5103

text to 5711

you know this will cause a huge controversary!!

 

[Kirby]

Nobody "wowed" me tonight. Thought it was all pretty blah. Though Constantine's song did bring back some happy memories. Am I dating myself?

 

[snoopy]

Great show tonight! Best was...
Nadia's hair! I kept thinking over the past few weeks that her smile reminded me of a cartoon character, but tonight between the hair and the smile, I finally realized who it was. Now I really like Nadia and she's a beautiful girl, but she looked like MAX, THE GRINCH'S DOG! You know, when he's weighed down by that one big antler in the middle of his head?

This has me laughing so hard I think I might have woke up the neighbors. I was looking at her thinking "who does she remind me of?"....I think you nailed it Mrs. Mud.

Uhhh, lets see, who did I like tonight? Definately Constantine. I like how he took the saccharine out of the Partridge family and allowed the melody to shine through....although I could definately do without that scrunching of the nose someone else mentioned they found attractive. I find it annoying and distracting.

Also loved Bo. He never disappoints. He might not be the best vocally, but he's got the confidence and experience to win the whole shebang.

I was very disappointed with Anwar tonight. I love his voice, but he was clearly out of his element tonight.

Scott is good vocally, but as DH says, he looks exactly like a Teletubby. He can only go so far with that look in a business that puts as much emphasis on pizzaz as it does talent.

Anthony, on the other hand, its a little hottie.....dang, did you ladies notice his, ummmmm, tight pants tonight? O.K., call me Mrs. Robinson, I can take it. Seriously, though, he's a nice looking guy, but he picks some boring songs to sing.

Nikko has a good groove going on, but he's nowhere near the other guys as far as sheer talent.

Of the girls, Nadia and Vonzell remain my favorites, even though this wasn't Nadia's night. Jessica is good also, but there is something about her I can't quite put my finger on that I don't like. Carrie is talented, but to steal a line from Simon, seems like someone who should be working in a themepark to me - she seems sort of fake and cutesy, not my cup of tea. And Mikayla is out of her league. Time for her to go.

 

[orangeblossom]

OMG - my DH just read on the Idol boards and we just watched it on our Tivo that they messed up the numbers for Mikayla, Anwar and Jessica

I edited to put the mistake in red

For Mikayla they put call
866-idols-09
866-436-5101

text to 5709

For Anwar they put call
866-idols-10
866-436-5102

text to 5710

For Jessica they put call
866-idols-11
866-436-5103

text to 5711

you know this will cause a huge controversary!!

OMG! And of course it was someone I liked that they screwed up on....I know I voted on the right number at least.

 

[eeyore0062]

I was FINALLY impressed with Carrie tonight. She should NEVER go back to Country!!!!

Loved "I Think I Love You"! Constantine did a great job and really looked like he was enjoying himself!

Scott was awesome tonight! Liked his choice of song and he really did a great job with his showmanship. Glad to see he had some supporters in the audience!

Vonzel was great! Honestly, one of her best performances.

Nadia... well, what can you say about the hairstyle? She certainly won't be forgotten. I like Cyndi Lauper, but I didn't think that it was really Nadia's thing.

Anthony... did I miss something? I don't understand why Simon said he was trying to "sex" it up, because he didn't look sexy to me. His voice is nice, but I don't think he is going to be around much longer.

Nikko did a great job, and kept his hand where they should be... what a relief! Liked his outfit, too!

Jessica... she is my favorite of the girls right now. She is consistant, and I love her voice! She did a great job, and something is wrong if she ends up in the bottom 3 this week.

Bo did a nice rendition of "Time In A Bottle". Great to hear him slow things down a bit and show a different side of himself. He is so comfortable on stage, he will have NO problem getting a recording deal with or without the title of American Idol.

Anwar... what can I say?... he IS my American Idol. I just love his voice, his look, his personality.... he is awesome. At first he seemed a little uncomfortable with the upbeat tune, but once he got into it, he really showed what he has!

AH, Mikalah.... I think this is her week.... to go home, that is! I thought through auditions that she really had potential... except her speaking voice grated on my nerves. But week by week, her voice seems to loose something. Maybe it is just that her vocal chords are wiped out. She does sound a lot like Taylor Daines, so I very much understand the song that she sang, but she just wasn't able to pull it off.

 

[ekmdisney]

Did every one who wanted to call in for Jessica get in at all?

I have been trying to call in on my cell phone, and each time it can't pick up a line. I don't get a busy signal or anything. My phone just says that its trying to connect. This has been doing this since the lines opened. Is anyone else having this problem?

As for tonights show, I though it was GREAT! Except for a few performances.

Mikalah, really needs to go HOME! She was the worst of the night. I love that song, and she butchered it!

I wasn't to impressed with Anthony, Nikko or Constantine. I won't be to suprised to see one of them in the bottom three.

I like Anwar and Nadia, but they need to work a little harder to find a song that really shows off their talent.

I also liked Vonzell and Scott, but I have a feeling that they will last long.

My favs of the night... Carri, Bo, Jessica. Jessica was a suprised for me tonight. I haven't been much of a fan. I hope she can pull it through again next week.

 

[Sandy22]

OMG - my DH just read on the Idol boards and we just watched it on our Tivo that they messed up the numbers for Mikayla, Anwar and Jessica

I edited to put the mistake in red

For Mikayla they put call
866-idols-09
866-436-5101

text to 5709

For Anwar they put call
866-idols-10
866-436-5102

text to 5710

For Jessica they put call
866-idols-11
866-436-5103

text to 5711

you know this will cause a huge controversary!!

I bet you no one goes home tomorrow! I think they'll just extend it another week. One more week of Mikayla

 

[julia & nicks mom]

I bet you no one goes home tomorrow! I think they'll just extend it another week. One more week of Mikayla

that's what I think - or they have another vote tomorrow night and then kick someone off on Thursday night

 

[eeyore0062]

Wow, there is NO WAY they will be able to get good results with those mistakes. I think they should reshow tonights show tomorrow night with correct numbers then have the results show on Thursday.

Do you think any of the producers have even realized the problem. It would be horrible to have someone voted off that didn't deserve it!

 

[StaceyA]

OMG - I LOVED to poof my bangs! Well the whole top of my head actually! Oh, and of course, I poofed out the sides too...really now...I had to keep it all in proportion! Needless to say...I had BIG hair!

Except the back...LOL mine looked like a lions mane from the back!

 

[StaceyA]

OMG - my DH just read on the Idol boards and we just watched it on our Tivo that they messed up the numbers for Mikayla, Anwar and Jessica

I edited to put the mistake in red

For Mikayla they put call
866-idols-09
866-436-5101

text to 5709

For Anwar they put call
866-idols-10
866-436-5102

text to 5710

For Jessica they put call
866-idols-11
866-436-5103

text to 5711

you know this will cause a huge controversary!!

I have been voting #3 for Scott, I hope I was calling the right #

 

[korzmom]

how hard can it be to post a few phone numbers!!!! sometimes I think its fixed. mikayla was awful, maybe she should try modeling....poor anwar - he was a bit boring and nadia- what was she thinking???? she looked like my little pony! really liked carrie tonight, thought she was the best...and constantine just brought back great memories...i was surprised they didnt interview donnie osmond and ask him who his fav. is.. i hope its not a do over next week show!

 

[StaceyA]

how hard can it be to post a few phone numbers!!!! sometimes I think its fixed.

My DH just said the same thing, a way to manipulate the voting on who stays and who goes.