Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

[Lisa loves Pooh]

does it cost anything to vote?

Phone calls are free...text messaging fees apply to cingular customers who text their vote.

Okay, I really like Bo.

I concur--anybody recall what the voting # was?

 

[Octoberbeauty]

does it cost anything to vote?

No, unless you text vote and then regular texting fees apply.

 

[6_Time_Momma]

Phone calls are free...text messaging fees apply to cingular customers who text their vote.


I concur--anybody recall what the voting # was?

He was 04, I believe.

 

[Poohbear123]

Thats who I voted for, they are the best I think.

 

[ShuisFan584]

I can't believe only 3 people tonight got positive feedback from the judges! I thought a lot of them did good. I was especially surprised about Anthony. After listening to him, my mom and I were just like "he is soooo amazing!" We knew he had to get good ratings from the judges, but they all said it was just OK and it was a safe song. Were we listening to the same performance?? All I know is that I'm definitely voting for him tonight, he just has to be in the top 12. I'll be surprised at whoever goes home on Wednesday night because I thought just about all of them did good.

 

[Octoberbeauty]

1-866-436 570 and then their contestant number of the night.

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

I can't believe only 3 people tonight got positive feedback from the judges! I thought a lot of them did good. I was especially surprised about Anthony. After listening to him, my mom and I were just like "he is soooo amazing!" We knew he had to get good ratings from the judges, but they all said it was just OK and it was a safe song. Were we listening to the same performance?? All I know is that I'm definitely voting for him tonight, he just has to be in the top 12. I'll be surprised at whoever goes home on Wednesday night because I thought just about all of them did good.

After many safe songs--I think I get what a safe song is....it is a song you choose for a talent show to win a trophy...not a talent showcase to win a recording contract. If they are not told the songs are just "safe"--then they won't broadent their horizons in their future choices.

 

[taekwondo mom]

1-866-436-57 then contestant #

 

[Cindy B]

anwars number has been busy and I can't get through

 

[Octoberbeauty]

Thats who I voted for, they are the best I think.

Whyyy, you have very good taste indeed!

There is some incredible talent this year!

 

[palmtreegirl]

Nikko- just not good.
Scott- wanted to like him but it was just OK.
Anthony- I like him but that song choice was a snoozer.
Bo-didn't do it for me but it might've been the song, I hate that song.
Travis- good looking guy but I didn't think he had a very good voice.
Constantine- It was eh.
David Brown- Zzzzzzzzz
Jared- don't really remember.
Anwar- Best of the night by far.
Judd- made me laugh, great entertainer, OK singer.
Joseph- bad song, didn't like at all.
Mario- what? they said he was the best? not feeling it at all.

My votes are going to Anwar! Gonna throw a couple to Anthony because I liked him so much before tonight and one to Judd because he made me laugh.

 

[disney4us2002]

The judges always seem to like the song selections I don't like and they call the ones I like 'safe' so I'm used to that. I like songs that demonstrate actual singing ability. I liked "How am I supposed to live without you." Does anyone know who that was? I'm terrible with names til they get down to the last 6 or so, lol.

 

[Cindy B]

too many boring songs tonight.

bo kicked bootay, and anwar was amazing.

Judd well, his pants were a bit tight.. even my ten year old noticed that.

Mario was pretty good as well.

Constantine just bleh tonight.. sorry...

 

[LadyBears]

I think Bo did awesome tonite!!

I liked Constantine, even though I don't care for the song he sang. He did "make it his own" because of his stage presence. He didn't just stand there like he was bored or scared the way a lot of the other guys did.

Most of the others were really to boring tonight to even consider safe.

I hope the girls do better.

 

[sweet angel]

Okay here are my top six after watching tonight's episode (in the order they performed):
Anthony
Bo
Constantine
Anwar
Judd
Mario
Gonna go vote now!

I'll agree, except for Anthony. I don't really think there's anything special about him. I voted for Constantine, but it took me 20 minutes and 2 phones to get through.

 

[PrincessaC]

I liked Mario. He got my vote!

 

[CookieGVB]

Tonight - Bo and Anwar, all the way

 

[Tina]

I voted for Bo. I really am beginning to dislike Constantine the more I see him. He just doesn't do it for me. I was very disappointed in Travis tonight. He's from my area, so I was really hoping to see him shine. While I voted for Bo, I hope that Travis makes it through to give it another try.

 

[Mickeyfaniam]

I thought they all did well so I just did not vote
Much more talent than last year

 

[Tasha+Scott]

Nikko- just not good.
Scott- wanted to like him but it was just OK.
Anthony- I like him but that song choice was a snoozer.
Bo-didn't do it for me but it might've been the song, I hate that song.
Travis- good looking guy but I didn't think he had a very good voice.
Constantine- It was eh.
David Brown- Zzzzzzzzz
Jared- don't really remember.
Anwar- Best of the night by far.
Judd- made me laugh, great entertainer, OK singer.
Joseph- bad song, didn't like at all.
Mario- what? they said he was the best? not feeling it at all.

Okay, I am going to use your format but enter my own opinions so here goes:
Nikko- I really liked him. He was my 3rd fave of the night.
Scott- Not his best song but still my favorite.
Anthony- I thought he had a lot of potential but didn't like his song choice.
Bo-My favorite performer of the night...he knew exactly what fit his voice and made it work.
Travis- good looking guy but I didn't think he had a very good voice. (I AGREE!!)
Constantine- Sorry, didn't do it for me.
David Brown- Zzzzzzzzz (I agree.)
Jared- bored me to tears.
Anwar- I know you all love him, but I wasn't too crazy about him myself.
Judd- made me laugh, great entertainer, OK singer. (I AGREE!)
Joseph- bad song, didn't like at all. (I AGREE!)
Mario- what? they said he was the best? not feeling it at all. (I AGREE!)

SO my faves so far are Scott, Bo, and Nikko. The 2 I hope get voted off this week simply b/c of their performance tonight would be Jared and Travis.