Offical American Idol Discussion Thread

[musicalSaranader]

Uh oh, I fear for my Johnny right now.... but why isn't Camille in the bottom three?

Oh my goodness THIS IS THE ABSOLUTE WRONG BOTTOM THREE!!! All three of them should still be safe! (Ok good LaToya is safe now.) Poor John knew he should have been in the bottom three over LaToya, poor boy looked like he was going to cry.

 

[Mickey's sunshine]

LaToya??? ok now I know something is wrong with America!!!!

I dont think I like this show.....my first season watching it too. UGH!!!

 

[Hootiss]

I am screaming at the t.v . This is crazy

 

[Poohbear123]

(For those that are on the West Coast/Mountains, and other areas).....AMY ADAMS!!!!! WOW! John Stevens is SAFE!

 

[izzy]

This is just SO wrong it's not even funny. I cannot believe that LaToya was in the bottom three. Who in the world keeps voting for Camille and John Stevens?!?!

I'm sick and tired of the teenyboppers in our country dictating our fashions, shoes, music, etc.

ARGHHHHH!!!!!!!

 

[Mickey's sunshine]

this SUCKS!!!! now we have to endure yet another crappy performance by Camille.....where is that pukey smilie???? (sorry Camille fans)

 

[Poohbear123]

Lets bring on the Puking Smilie PLEASE!!!! Christine!

 

[damo]

Well, you'd think that the judges would have learned after three seasons that the sympathy vote goes a long way. It's their fault. I would rather have seen Jennifer leave than Amy.

 

[Lanshark]

I watched it for the first time last week and for the last time this week. Now I remember why I have NEVER watched reality TV. Because there is no reality to it.

 

[elgerber]

I knew you guys would be here screaming already!!! I am soooooooooo mad!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I was mad when they said Amy was in the bottom 3 and it just got worse from there. What is going on??? That was so wrong. I loved Amy, she would not have won it all, but she is so much better than several of the people who are still there. And LaToya in the bottom 3? John was so bad last night, it was almost painful. Grrrrrr. He did look like he was going to cry, he's so young, I hope he can handle that kinda stress. Anyone else think living in that house will be boring now that Amy's gone? She had so much more personality than all the rest.

Erika

 

[MScott1851]

You could tell that John KNEW he should be in the bottom three instead of LaToya...the look on his face said it all...

I think that Amy should take the advice from two shows ago, and head to Nashville and knock the socks off country music...It needs a little shot in the arm and I think she could do it!!

 

[Mickey's sunshine]

my good buddy Faith.

Damo, I agree - would rather see Jennifer go.

Erika - yes alot more boring now that Amy is gone.

OK, we need a recount!!!!

 

[mrsv98]

I am OUTRAGED!!!!!!

They are going to have to figure out a way to keep the teeny boppers from voting a million times. This is ridiculous, John Stevens knew darn well he had no business being "safe", he looked like he was going to cry. And even if Camille was slightly better, she still has no place on stage with the others. If AI can't figure out a way to keep the voting fair, it is going to loose its appeal, at least to me.

Geesh!

 

[chelsea&austinsmom]

I really liked Amy I don't think she deserved to go this week.

 

[cheeringmom]

Poor Amy. The wrong move America. Poor John looked so guilty too.....not his fault however!! But Camille????

 

[beattyfamily]

It just shows that people are not voting for the best. They are assuming everyone else is voting for good ones.

That happened a couple times last year and the year before...it's a wake up call when a good one is in the bottom 3.

I know everyone thinks JS should go and stunk last night but I still like him and hold out hope for him. I know he'll do great on Big Band week. He has an amazing voice but only for one kind of music. Big Band. He could definitely be the next Harry Connick Jr. I guess I like rooting for the underdog.

None of the other sings do anything for me except Jasmine (sp?). If she ever got into the bottom 3, I would vote for her like crazy from then on but because she's so good, I vote for JS. I know, I know you all think he stinks!

I'm sick of Jennifer. She yells the songs and makes weird faces.

I will just die if Fantasia wins! She bugs me to no end.

 

[TiggerPiglet]

I totally agree about the sympathy vote. I think it really works against the good singers. The fans of the singers who were flamed will get out and vote, while the singers who were praised will not get voted for, because their fans think they're safe. They really need to change something. If LaToya would have gone, I think I might have stopped watching

 

[damo]

Here's another non teenie bopper who is glad that JS is still there.

 

[Pixie_Dust]

Wow, you know the results already? Makes it not worth watching. We love Amy even more than Matt. Why do the majority of voters have such bad taste? Waah!

We voted for George, btw.

 

[Nancy]

I am stunned by the bottom 3! It should have been Camille, John S and JPL. When it was down to LaToya and John I figured it would be John...boy was I shocked! Poor John..he looked as stunned as I felt. Why Camille wasn't in the bottom 3 I'll never understand. Out of the 3 in the bottom tonight I thought Jennifer should have gone. I really wasn't liking her attitude while she was standing there but then I figured it was probably a defense mechanism.

So what is our music theme next week?