I worked in a daycare before my daughter was born, so I really didn't have high expectations. Though the child/CM ratio was higher than allowed in a DC daycare, it was 4-1 on the ship, though it was definitely higher than that on at least 2 nights. That's why I said it's better for 1 and 2 year olds, because they can handle a higher ratio since they do not need to be carried, held, fed, etc. like an infant does. The night we decided not to drop her off, another parent was waiting to check-in with her 2.5yo daughter, and she said it looked very crowded too and that they told her that if it gets overcrowded they bring in CMs from the Lab or Club. They may do this, but htey hadn't as of the time I was there so we left. Also, they didn't charge us for that night, probably because they were glad to have one less kid. Really though, when it comes to your child, should you have low expectations about childcare?
The reason I said they leave them sleeping unattended in cribs in the back is because they told us that. When we arrived the first night, my daughter had just fallen asleep so they said "You can put her in one of the cribs in the back room, pick any one you like." So I did, though I knew she'd wake up once I put her down, I figured I'd give it a try. While I was doing this, one of the CMs came back there with my husband and I and he asked her what they do with sleepers in these cribs and she said they were checked on every 20-30 minutes. I'm sure she would not have said this if it weren't true. This was the 1st night of the cruise and there was only 1 other baby there so at this time they were not understaffed so there would be no reason for her to say that if it weren't true. She woke up as soon as I put her down anyway so it wasn't an issue. My daughter liked it enough the first night as when we picked her up around 45 minutes later she was relaxed in a rocking chair with a CM. Like I said, though, that night wasn't crowded at all so I'm sure that made the difference. Also, every CM who worked there was very friendly and nice, I never encountered a rude one. I was very upset that they didn't page my when my daughter was crying for a long time, instead of just leavign her in the swing, but I really only attribute that to them being overcrowded and not having a chance to use the phone, as when I went in the room she was in to get her, a very nice CM was sitting next to her swing on the floor, with 5 or 6 other little ones in the room with her. We liked her a lot though and she really seemed to like my daughter, but they simply didn't have enough staff in there.