If they are having trouble filling tables, it doesn't matter that it's unique. We have never eaten at WCC because, as you said, there are tons of other places to eat that are more appealing. We may try WCC now that it will be quieter. It was mentioned on the other thread that WL is a deluxe resort and the constant deafening noise from Whispering Canyon sort of detract from the upscale (and very expensive) ambiance in the lobby. I'm sure the management was okay with that if tables are always full, but if not, why not make some adjustments to see how it affects dining reservations there?
I was specifically interested to see that the pony races won't start until after 10:00 am. I have stayed at WL a few times and wanted a table service breakfast option with no screaming or antics and settled for Roaring Forks since there was no assurance of a quiet meal at WCC even if you "opted out" of the antics.
And yes, I realize what a grump I sound like. Stay off my lawn! Just wanted to share the alternate perspective - we like other schtick (Trader Sam's comes to mind) but this theme, the noise, and the rude server bit has never appealed to us.