Well in a nut shell what I have to look at is, the amount in family, although space is great and I do love to be comfortable, its not the biggest issue. But is it a major deal on which resort I do purchase into? I mean if I join with AKV, yes the Savannah view is great, but I dont know of Im into the whole theme of it. I know that sounds silly. I am so drawn into the new Bay Lake Tower (which may be already sold out), but its the highest of points. But I much rather look at MK and fireworks and love the style of the rooms.
Its hard to decide because I can either way stay where I want as long as its available, so how do I decided my home resort. its too hard. arrhhh!!!
I agree that one of the hardest decisions is choosing home resort and comparing that to the cost of getting that resort.
Right now, with the exception of a few contracts (which would cost more), BLT is only available through Disney. The MF"S for BLT are the lowest right now but the cost per point is the highest at $112 (though if you purchase a minimum of 160, they are offering $5.00 per point discount). If you really feel that you want to be there, then that is where you should buy. If you really are not sure, then you should take the time to investigate the other resorts.
If you are looking for the most value, then SSR resale contracts seem to be the best deals out there cost wise. You can get contracts that are going between $65.00 - $75.00 per point, the expiration is 2054 (compared to some of the other resorts that expire in 2042) and the MF's are not that bad (about $4.60ish). However, it is a big resort and you have to be happy with staying there if there are no rooms at other resorts available at the 7 month mark.
Of course, if you find that you would not be booking your trips during the home resort advantage (11 - 8 months), then home resort is a lot less important since you will be competing with everyone for all the resorts at that point.
I just bought in to
DVC last month through both resale and direct. I knew that I really wanted BLT but did not want to commit to the 160 minimum for new members so I bought a small contract to become a member and than added on at BLT with less points. However, I have always stayed at the Contemporary and knew that spending the extra money for BLT was worth it--plus, I travel the same time every year and will always book at 11 months out.
Renting is a great idea to investigate if DVC is right for you. There is a lot of information over at the rent/transfer boards. Good luck and keep asking questions! I learned a lot before making my final decisions and am very happy that I had the knowledge I did before committing to years of DVC!!!