But first, here are some good thoughts for zurgswife's dd--I hope to be seeing good news here the next time I'm reading this thread.
And now, back to the Swan. My dh and I will be staying there in 72 days! It's our first time there. We booked it because they were offering such a great AP discount when WDW wasn't offering any AP discounts and we wanted to pin down our dates. I've read such great things about S/D here on the DIS, so I felt relatively secure about booking this trip.
Meanwhile, of course

, I've found things to worry about!
(1) I saw a post somewhere here on the DIS where someone mentioned that they had extremely noisy neighbors at the Swan one weekend. That was the first I'd heard of noise at either the Swan or the Dolphin and it freaked me out! I've been assuming that the Swan will be ultra quiet--which is very very important to us. Our last trip to WDW (in January) we were miserable at ASMu, which was unbearably noisy--I was unable to sleep. This leads me to question 2....
(2) It never occurred to us in January (when we were staying at ASMu) to ask to switch resorts, but now I realize we could have done just that and Disney would have accommodated us somehow.
However because we're staying at the Swan this time, if we don't like it there for some (or several or any) reason, basically, we're stuck there (or the Dolphin)--right? I mean, it's not a WDW hotel, so they've got noplace else to send us if we're not happy there.
I'm not expecting to hate it there, but we weren't expecting to despise ASMu either. [I realize there's no comparison between ASMu and the Swan--I'm just using it as an example.

] (BTW, the 2nd half of our January vacation was spent at AKL, which we loved, and we'd stay there again in December, but we wanted to try somewhere new.)
(3) I've read several reviews now that seem to emphasize the lack of "Disney magic" at the Swan. What do you guys think? I mean, I know there are no Mickey soaps or wake-up calls, but is it lacking in some other way?
(4) I've also read some reviews (here and on tripadvisor) that say the CMs at the S/D are not up to WDW standards. Yes? No?
TIA for all your help. We're going to be staying at the Swan for 9 nights and would like to feel relatively sure we're going to be happy there. This was our "bonus" trip as we have APs and wanted to use them again before they expire...and we unfortunately

don't expect to be back at WDW again for at least 2 or 3 years after this December.
And apologies for the overlong post.
--miffy--