Haven't read the thread. Did look at page 1. A few comments:
While I think that Disney Wishes follows the similar theme for ship names, I don't think they would go for it as it starts with W like the Wonder.
I don't think they would choose Imagination only because Carnival has a ship by that name that name. Yes, Carnival also has the Magic, but that launched after the Disney Magic.
I can absolutely see them choosing Believe for a ship name.
I'm surprised Disney Vision isn't listed on possible names, although I realize that
Royal Caribbean has a ship by that name. It's catchy though and still evokes that fantasy like theme of the other ships.
Another one not on the page 1 list is Disney Illusion. Yes, very similar to Magic, but not the same and I can't think of another line that uses it.
I also like the Disney Empress, with it's tie to the Pirates movies and opportunity for a Chinese theme with Mulan as the atrium character. I don't see them using this though, especially if they pick Disney Enchantment (which I think is the strongest possibility from the names on page 1).
Another one not on the list is the Disney Sorcerer. I can see that name taking shape. That's a medieval England setting that would set up for that type of theme for the atrium character (e.g Rapunzel). The name also evokes the same fantasy flair and allows for the Fantasia theme for bow/aft art as well.
The pattern I'm thinking Disney is going to go for is something that aligns with the current ship names in some way (Wonderment, Fantasy, Magical, Dreamy). At the same time, it should tie into something of the Disney existing franchise of movies, be unique in the industry and among the fleet and provide some sort of theme for the ship that could be carried out in the restaurants, pubs and atrium settings. A lot of the names from the list on Page 1 are a complete departure from the direction Disney has been going in. Since the ships don't look like a complete departure, I don't think the names will be either.