That's a toughie!!! They are both fantabulous!!! DH and I probably liked the food better at Narcoosee's...I personally like the ambience better at California Grill. Our service was impeccable at both places. Well, I don't think this really answers your question, but I don't think you can go wrong with either one. It really depends on the kind of experience you want. Narcoossee's is a little more elegant, I think, and Cal Grill is more contemporary...I was more relaxed at Cal Grill. As I said earlier, the food is WONDERFUL at both.