Do you have any children going with you? When we went last (May 06) my DD6 LOVED the Princess Storybook Dinner. The Princesses were wonderful. We saw Ariel (in her ballgown), Aurora, Belle (in her blue dress), Mulan and Jasmine. The food is actually pretty good and the wait staff is WONDERFUL at helping you through their tough menu. They will make any substitutions that you want. Also, I would ask to be sat by the door that the Princesses come out of. We sat there and when Aurora came out of the door I thought my DD6 was going to fall out of her chair she was so excited. After that they just kept on coming..
Also my DD6 LOVED the 1900 Park Fare Dinner with Cinderella, Prince Charming, Fairy Godmother and 2 of the Mice (Perla and Suzi). I think their buffet was really good and my DD6 liked it as well.
We also love the Crystal Palace (Pooh and Friends) their food is wonderful, especially the breakfast lasagna.
Next year we are going to
Crystal Palace - breakfast
Cinderella's Castle - lunch
1900 Park Fare - Dinner
Princess Storybook - breakfast
Chef Mickey - breakfast
We also would to try the CM at Liberty Tavern but I don't think that we can do 3 CM's in one day..