I don't think Kilimanjaro is overrated. I think it's a brilliant engineering design (though, that's my opinion) and it makes me appreciate the ride more than a zoo or a drive-through safari park. I do like most rides because of how they work, though. PLUS - it's Animal Kingdom! Not a zoo. ;p
I also like Haunted Mansion because of the illusions they applied - even though the tricks are old, they still execute them well. I do wish the outside were more like DL and that they had the HM holidays - but only because I LOVE Nightmare Before Christmas. I think, too, if POTC were more like DL, I'd like it more, too.
Same with Splash Mountain. I just don't like how gypped I feel when I go to DL and then go to WDW and see that the rides are shorter.
But this applies more heavily to Space Mountain! That ride is a total rip-off - especially if you rode the one at
Disneyland!! It doesn't have music, you can see the track, it's rickety and bangs you around! That ride in WDW is a total disappointment. The DL one doesn't go much faster than it, but at least the music and the fact that the track is smooth, and you can't see it makes it a very awesome experience. (And I REALLY love the music - by the same composer who did Speed Racer.)
Other disappointments: Stitch, Monster's Inc, Nemo (these rides are just not cute enough to make up for the lack of stimulation they provide), Toy Story Mania (it's just not worth the wait, especially when it's not that much different from Buzz), Narnia, Dumbo...and I enjoyed It's A Small World as a kid, but, like a lot of MK rides, it really needs an update or something.
And pretty much...all the rides at Epcot (except TT - I do like it for some reason) need to go and be replaced with something worth the wait. I love Epcot. I love the shops, the food, and all the stuff there is to look at...but I really don't like the Figment ride (the old one was better), I don't like Honey I Shrunk the Audience, Mission Space, Spaceship Earth (what a boring subject...almost as bad as the Carousel of Progress), the Mexico and Norway rides need an update or something, and, of course, Soarin could be better.
As for shows that I don't like:
I don't care much for the parades and block parties. I remember a time at MGM where they'd have parades based on the new movies coming out and I really miss that. And even when they weren't based on movies, I remember the parades being a bigger affair than they are now. It seems like the parade floats are getting smaller and less detailed.
SpectroMagic, also, isn't as cool as the Main Street Electrical Parade. I feel like that parade had more lights and glitter somehow. And they floats are soooooo tall! My favorite was the Captain Hook one. It shoots.
I also think Wishes isn't as cool as "Remember Dreams Come True" at Disneyland. =\ I wish they'd stop giving Disneyland all the good stuff.
But don't get me wrong, I'm a total WDW fangirl. I'll still ride these rides and have a nice time. It's just if I were to nitpick.... ;p