We went to the party on 10/5 and had a great time! We didn't really follow our itinerary though! I had thought about meeting Mickey in Town Square, but decided to ditch that, and due to DHs unexpected interest in getting photos and the kids unexpectedly wanting to meet up, it threw everything out of whack. Even so, was had so much fun and really got everything I wanted done.
DH and I arrived about 6:45 (DS14 and DF15 were already there). The whole atmosphere seemed so festive and Halloweeny

We got in line for the pumpkin shot in the middle of Town Square. The line looked long but moved quickly and it was fun looking around at everyone's costumes while we waited. Afterward, the bypass was still open so we meandered that way and got several pictures, including the poison apple magic shot. We headed over to HM from there and only waited about 15 minutes to board. When we were leaving the ride, we got a fun surprise - Madame Leota was heading towards the ride and we were able to get a picture with her. Really fun interaction. When we were saying goodbye, she told us to go out and enjoy life because she didn't have one
While we waited in line for the carriage magic shot, we got another surprise...the kids texted to suggest we meet up! I really hadn't planned on seeing them all night

They were just getting on a ride though, so we wandered around Liberty Square for awhile and ran into a Photopass photographer standing on her own near Columbia Harbour House. She did the hitchhiking ghost magic shot with us. I went back later to look for her to get one for the kids but she was gone, so I don't know where she ended up. We also checked the line for Jack and Sally around 8 before meeting the kids. It was about 1.5 hours long, which was longer than we wanted, but shorter than it's been on other party days I think. We checked back about an hour later and it was about the same.
After meeting the kids, we all went to ride BTMR, which was a walk-on. We then went around the park trick-or-treating. I didn't find that the CMs were overly generous with candy, just a few pieces per person. But it was still pretty early and I know they get more generous the later it gets. The Philharmagic stop was really neat and we stopped to watch the Sleepy Hollow cartoon for a few minutes. At this point, the kids went back to ride HM and get the carriage picture. DH and I did a little shopping and wandered to Main St to get a spot for the fireworks. I hung around while DH went to get a pumpkin waffle sundae (he loved it.) The kids were going to join us, but decided they wanted hot dogs from Casey's, so while the did watch, it was not with us. The fireworks were great. Lots of music from Nightmare, which I love.
After the fireworks, I was planning to head to Frontierland to find a spot for all of us to watch the second parade together. DH really wanted to watch from Main St though, so we headed toward the castle to look for spots in the loop. BAD IDEA! I had forgotten that there was a Hocus Pocus show between the fireworks and the parade, so there were lots of people rushing toward the stage. We did manage to find a spot, though, and like good rule-following guests, we sat behind the tape. Of course, three people came and sat in front of us. I was annoyed, but I shouldn't have been because CMs made them move. The parade was wonderful. Our kids were so impressed with the Headless Horseman riding through and we all just loved the grave diggers.
After the parade, it was our turn to rush the stage for the Hocus Pocus show. We got great spots only a couple of rows in. The show was probably my favorite thing about the night. It was just so, so good. It almost felt like being a part of the movie. After the show we started heading out. I was still hoping to get the Headless Horseman magic shot, but it was pretty late and we were all tired since we'd been in the parks since 8am. So although I saw some photographers taking photos where I think it would have been we skipped it. We really wanted to get a Minnie van, but apparently they stop running at midnight, so we waited for about 15 minutes before a bus came for the beach club. By the time we got back to our room and got settled for the night, it was almost 2am.
I didn't end up getting either of the two Magic Shots I had planned on but somehow managed to get all the ones I hadn't planned on! Totally fine, although in retrospect I wish we had stopped for the Horseman. I definitely want to do this party again. I think as a second-time visitor, I would do a few more rides. As first-timers, DH and I were just so taken by the atmosphere and we found ourselves just wanting to wander around and take it all in!