Originally posted by lark
We were just there and I actually thought it was quite lame who gets to the hot seat. We went to the show twice. On the fastest finger, which is how they generally decide the first player, there is no way to win other than to guess and push the buttons in random order. Since it's a 1/16 chance, the priority is on speed not figuring out the question. Both times we saw FF, the winning time was less than half a second, which obviously was not the result of someone actually figuring out the question.
With respect to the rest of the game, just note that you're going up against some serious pros. Each time we went, they had to go deeper and deeper on the list, because the winner would have to fess up that they had been there in the last 30 days. One time, the winner had to say no, the second person had to say no, and was a brother of the person who had won, and the third highest points was also in the same family and played. What was worse about it was that they all simply had guessed at answers to get there. One guy who got the FF in .4 seconds was essentially a moron who couldn't even get past 1,000 points without using lifelines on pretty simple questions. Everyone we saw who was in the hot seat all admitted that they had been there multiple times. When the arena is full, 650 people is generally enough that sheer guessing for speed will enable someone to get in in front of people playing the game straight up.
It would be a better attraction, in my opinion, if there was some feeling as though you didn't have to know tricks to make it and that it put some premium on knowing correct answers. For example, on the FF, I would make it so that everyone who got the question correct in 5 seconds or less would have a chance at the hot seat; the computer would pick one at random. Same with the points -- I'd make it so that the top 25 or so all had a random chance. It would be nice to think that if you only visit once every couple of years or so you still have some semblance of a chance, other than as part of a complete guessing lottery.