Mama Melrose or Alfredo's?

[FINFAN]

Main objective is the calamari appetizer...DD makes a meal of it. Also, I did not see chicken fingers/nuggets on MM menu ( I must be blind) but did see it on Alfredos for DS. We will be on the free DDP, MM will be more convenient based on the park plans we have, but no biggie to hop a friendship boat to Epcot! We have never eaten at either place if that makes a difference!

TIA,


Pam

 

[Cinderumbrella]

We may be in the minority but we love Alfredos! Mama Melrose is OK- but just that- OK.
I'm pretty sure DH had calamari at Alfredos and said it was really good!

 

[GinaGrumpyDwarf]

Personally i have never liked Alfredos, and we LOVE Mamma's. So my vote is for Mamma's!!

 

[cocodog]

The calamari st MM is very good. Otherwise, I tend to prefer the food at Alfredo's. However, MM is not bad at all, and the service when we were there for diner was excellent! Make sure to try the honey- ricotta cheesecake if you eat at MM!

 

[FINFAN]

I was leaning towards MM, but checked again...no chicken fingers! Not sure now...DS is not a big italian lover, maybe he can eat the pasta plain...BUT....it's DD's choice overall, since DS chose Sci Fi!
Thanks for the help!


Pam

 

[tinkerbeth]

For me it depends on what you're after. If you want "authenitc" Italian, Alfredo's is better imho. Dh and I lived in Italy for 2 years and we really liked Alfredo's b/c the servers and cooks are Italian and we found the menu similar to what we would find in Italy.

I've found MM to be more like "NY Italian" which I also really like, and I think it is considerably cheaper. I liked MM a lot when we went and we're going back.

We liked both so have fun either way!

Beth