I think it's really fascinating juxtaposing the comments in this thread with a lot of the assertions in this article:
http://www.wired.com/2015/03/disney-magicband/
It's particularly interesting if you focus on this paragraph:
The redesigned Disney World experience constrains choices by dispersing them, beginning long before the trip is under way. “There are missions in a vacation,” Staggs says. In other words, Disney knows that parents arrive to its parks thinking: We have to have tea with Cinderella, and where the hell is that Buzz Lightyear thing, anyway? In that way, the park isn’t a playground so much as a videogame, with bosses to be conquered at every level. The MagicBands let you simply set an agenda and let everything else flow around what you’ve selected. “It lets people’s vacations unfold naturally,” Staggs says. “The ability to plan and personalize has given way to spontaneity.” And that feeling of ease, and whatever flows from it, just might make you more apt to come back.
The thing is, the article focuses on the end effect and assumes parents/vacationers are successful when they try to book these things. I share in your frustration
2olddisneynutz. When I booked our honeymoon for December 2013, I was up at 6 a.m. to make our dining reservations, and I was only able to secure one out of our list. It was my first time going to WDW, so I was really peeved. The only reason we secured a dinner at BOG is because a kind DISer gave us her reservation that she was canceling. We were able to get a couple of our other choices later on. I just kept checking back.
It's funny that the WIRED article emphasizes Disney's technological advances when its web site is glitchy AF, and the app isn't much better. In theory it's a great system... but user stories on this board illustrate otherwise.
Since my mother and I planned a vacation last minute just a few weeks ago, I knew we were already screwed on ADRs... We're already past the 6-month opening date. We were successful in scoring a reservation at Cinderella's castle, which is cool. No luck with BOG of course... but at least I've experienced that once before now.