We really like Liki Tiki and are going in three weeks! I think it depends on the age of the family. Our kids loved Liki Tiki. We went last year with my parents. They have a timeshare in Williamsburg and traded it for us to have a vacation in Florida. We were there for two weeks in late Feb/early March. My dad, 75, kept saying it was not as nice as Williamsburg. I think think it was as "classy" as their condo in Williamsburg.
I liked our condo. It was roomy - more tropical decor but this is Florida - and I loved being able to eat outside on the balcony. Our kids were 9,7,3, when we went and they loved the splash park. It was perfect for their ages. I can see if they were teens maybe not as much. The two regular pools were nice for swimming but have no extras like bigger slides or anything. The pools were never crowded or the splash park.
We liked the location. It took us about 10-15 minutes to get to the parks. Anyway, we liked it so much we bought a timeshare on ebay at Liki Tiki and are headed down in a few weeks.
We are a family of 5. We did the regular "hotel" vacation thing this summer and we missed the room of a timeshare. That is a big plus for us.
The price is also right at Liki Tiki. Last year it was free thanks to Mom and Dad and we got a great deal on Ebay so we feel good about it. I would love to go to DVC but don't think we could afford that! This way we can afford Disney two years in a row.