Lightroom, Photoshop....both?

MikeandReneePlus5

DIS Veteran
Joined
Sep 28, 2010
Messages
2,136
What is the difference between these and do you need on of the other or both?

I am a learning amateur, not a graphic artist or someone looking for commercial level prints.

I read the web pages but it's corporate speak:

>>>Lightroom includes all the tools you need for most digital photography tasks in one intuitive solution. Lightroom helps photographers work faster and more efficiently with one image, a set of images, or a large image library. Adobe Photoshop software is the industry standard in digital image editing, with advanced tools used by photographers, graphic designers, and other graphics professionals when they need complete control to perform detailed, pixel-level editing and to work with multilayered files.<<<

So it sounds like Photoshop is for heavy duty pixel level editing and LR is more user friendly? :confused3
 
lightroom will allow you to adjust exposure, white balance sharpness. etc, fatser easier and do batch processing, it is also a great caataloging tool,


photoshop although the industry standard is overkill for most people, either adobe elements, or corels paint shop pro, are less expensive and will do what most people need it to do, cloning out objects, more in depth processing than lightroom

I've used paint shop pro for years, veryhappy with it, decided to buy lightroom last august to process a wedding I shot, figutred the batch processing would be better for me, I love lightroom, now do all my basic processing with it, turning to paint shop pro only when I wnt to get creative
 
If you just want RAW processing and basic editing along with great image management tools, Lightroom will do it for you. I use both Lightroom and Photoshop CS5. I do 80% of my editing in Lightroom but it's not a substitute for Photoshop for the more advanced editing tools I sometimes need. (often for selective sharpening or color correction with masks)

Download the free trials at Adobe.com. Try them for 30 days and see which one works best for you.
 
I just found out the new LR4 is 50% cheaper than before.

I had decided last year $300 might be a bit much right now.

But $149 sure sounds a lotttt better. :banana:
 

light room is all i use. as said above easy for simple edit and clean up. Catalog and set up your folder plus easy upload to flickr.

Photo shop you can change anything in the photo. I go by the rule of take the photo you want not make the photo you want.

-Dan
 
Thanks.

I have a basic question that believe it or not I can't find an easy answer to! So many people and web sites are so far beyond the basics that this kind of simple question isn't answered (or my google skills stink).

Anyway...will LR be all I need to import, edit, export, buy and organize pictures?

Right now I import off my camera using the Canon EOS Utility. They go into My Pictures in Windows 7 and I prefer the to go into "shooting month".

Then I open Canon DPP and make some edits.

then I go to Zoombrowser to look at slide shows or show to family, and I organize within Zoombrowser by creating new folders and dragging pictures.

When I want to use Flickr or Photobucket I go to those websites and use their upload features to find my photos on my hard drive and upload. When I want to buy prints I upload to Kodak (soon to be Shutterfly) via their upload tool.

How much of all that does LR do?

I really appreciate any answers to what is a fairly tedious topic for experienced workflow people I'm sure.

Thanks.

ETA: I am definitely going to download LR4 and play with it...but right now I don't have a lot of RAW images so I want to shoot a bit first. In the meantime this basic info would be great to know!
 
Anyway...will LR be all I need to import, edit, export, buy and organize pictures?

Yes. You can set it up to import when you put a memory card in the computer. As long as you're just talking more basic editing and RAW processing (as in not cloning, head swapping, etc) it will meet that. And you can get a plug in for LR that sends it to a site where you can buy pictures. An example, I use smugmug and have the plug in to upload directly from lightroom. It has extensive organization tools, from metadata tags to a flagging system. It also has the ability to sort by EXIF data information, like if you want to find every shot with your 50mm f/1.8, you can.
 
Yes. You can set it up to import when you put a memory card in the computer. As long as you're just talking more basic editing and RAW processing (as in not cloning, head swapping, etc) it will meet that. And you can get a plug in for LR that sends it to a site where you can buy pictures. An example, I use smugmug and have the plug in to upload directly from lightroom. It has extensive organization tools, from metadata tags to a flagging system. It also has the ability to sort by EXIF data information, like if you want to find every shot with your 50mm f/1.8, you can.

thank you...for this and ALLLLLL your helpful posts. you've answered so many of my questions!

really appreciate it.

PS I did find a great article on Importing right on the Adobe LR page. Don't know how I missed it the first go round.
 
I have my import into lightroom when I hook up my camera. From there I can split the (new) folders and (new) imports. I can upload from lightroom right to flickr. As lightroom has a flickr plug in.
 
I wasn't sure what all Lightroom did, to be honest, but fell for the "add it for only" popup on the Adobe site when I purchased CS6. Now I'm so glad I have it because I can't imagine trying to work without it.

It allows you to quickly import and organize your photos. In addition to helping you organize them on disk while importing, you can also create collections to sort them on a large variety of filtering tools. There are even smart collections that will automatically add photos to themselves based on keywords, exif data or even geotag data. (For example, if you create a smart collection based on a circle you draw around Epcot on a map and have a camera with GPS capability, any photo you upload from Epcot will automatically add itself to the Epcot smart collection. If your camera doesn't do GPS, you can drag your photos onto a map in Lightroom to geotag them yourself.)

There are great tools in Lightroom for adjusting the look of photos. It won't do fancy editing, as others have said, but it will give you what you need to work with most of your RAW photos. (Complex tasks that require masking or smart erasing, for example, will need another tool like Photoshop CS6 or Photoshop Elements.)

There are tools for creating slide shows and photo books, and integrated tools to upload and maintain your photos on most of the major photo sharing sites like Photobucket, Flickr, Smugmug, Facebook, and Adobe Revel. You can also set Lightroom to automatically add a copyright watermark to your photos as it uploads them. If you have geotag (map) data in Lightroom, you can set it to transmit this info when you upload photos online. For example, my photos are automatically added to my Flickr map if I've mapped them in Lightroom.

The Lightroom map feature itself is really cool. You can view a satellite map, zoom in on a location, and click to see the photos you took at that location.

Another feature that I also really like is the ability to sync changes you've made in one photo to many photos. For example, if you've taken a series of photos in the same location that have a similar look, when you make changes to exposure, contrast, color, white balance, etc., you can sync those changes to the other photos and not have to do them all individually.

I agree with the recommendation of a previous poster. If we haven't convinced you that you need this tool, download the free trial from Adobe and give it a test drive. Also, check out some of the training videos for Lightroom on Adobe TV (their free online training site). http://tv.adobe.com/product/lightroom/

And my final piece of advice, before you buy anything from Adobe, please check to see if your household qualifies for the education discount. It will save you a lot of money. Lightroom is only $79 with this discount. You need to have either a .edu email address or upload copies of a student/teacher/faculty ID and/or other documentation to activate the product.

Adobe Web Site qualifications for education discount said:
Students
You must provide official, current proof of enrollment in one of the following:

  • Accredited* public or private primary or secondary school providing full-time instruction
  • Accredited* higher education institution that grants degrees requiring not less than the equivalent of two years of full-time study
  • Homeschool — as defined by state homeschooling regulations

Teachers, faculty, and staff
You must provide official, current proof that you are employed by one of the following:

  • Accredited* primary or secondary school
  • Accredited* public or private university or college
  • School district or board of education (including emeritus status professors)
  • Homeschool — as defined by state homeschooling regulations
 
If you want to get a book on pretty much everything Lightroom can do, maybe check out Scott Kelby's Lightroom 4 for Digital Photographers. I have his LR3 version, and absolutely love it. Very easy to read and follow. And he can be pretty amusing too.
 
Do you have school age kids? If so, check out the educational software sites for the best prices. I bought my LR3 from Journey Ed a couple years ago and got a great price at the time.
 
Lightroom/Photoshop is certainly a powerful combination. If you don't shoot RAW, you might find Photoshop Elements to be good enough. It's got a nice Catalog system to organize photos, and the Elements Editor is more than enough pixel editing for 99% of us.

You could also use Lightroom along with the Photoshop Elements editor instead of Photoshop.

The main things you lose by using Photoshop Elements are easy batch job handling and a lot of plug-ins and actions will only work in Photoshop. Some do work in both though.
 
just to say that Lightroom4 is AMAZING.

it is so easy to use. Very intuitive. I was impressed with how I could just begin to figure out what to do by looking at the interface and simply using common sense.

I had seen enough of Photoshop over the years to be intimidated. LR is not intimidating at all. Eventually I can get into the nitty gritty of how it works but the left to right, top to bottom workflow is really simple to get a handle on it and you can be up and running making pictures better in a matter of minutes.

Also...thanks for the head's up on pricing. With 5 kids in the house there are plenty of opportunities for learning and we qualify for the student pricing which is now..... $54 on Amazon. :)

just in case there are other newbies like me out there that don't have it or didn't want to spend $150 for it.....for $54 it's a no-brainer IMO...if all you got were the Adjustment Brushes it would be worth that price but you get a lot more.
 
When I import a RAW file to LR, I understand no processing is applied to that image...i.e. it is straight out of the camera. I also understand I can set a preset to apply some basic developing tools on Import like shaprening or contrast or what have you.

How about with a JPEG? the camera makes some decisions and creates that JPEG right? when I bring that into LR, I assume all those camera adjs are baked in?

Said another way, for the JPEG snapshots one does not plan on processing at all...they'll still look in LR as they do on the camera LCD.

I just don't want to have JPEG images look worse than they do in-camera!
 
You are correct that with a jpeg the camera has already applied the settings. It's like processed film at that point. You can still technically make any changes to the image that you can with a RAW file, it's just a lot more difficult to do so without some loss of image quality and it takes Photoshop and not just Lightroom most of the time.

Will the jpeg looks like it does on the LCD... not exactly. THe LCD is a tiny little screen that hides flaws, especially poor focus. The color and contrast will vary between different sources as well. But the file information will not change between the camera and viewing the file in Lightroom so it's technically the same image.
 
I'm so not technical. I can do what I need to do, but could never explain to anyone why ... Other than I use LR4 now over PhotoShop. I just really like it.
 
Said another way, for the JPEG snapshots one does not plan on processing at all...they'll still look in LR as they do on the camera LCD.

As answered they'll be the same.

However - One more thing to note - ALL editing in Lightroom is non-destructive to the original image file unless/until you 'Export' the file to the original filename.

If you edit a .JPG image you will see the adjustments on your screen and you can also print them, but what Lightroom is actually doing is creating a 'script' of the changes that you have made relative to the original image which it then uses whenever it shows the image or prints the image. Every time you open Lightroom the image will look just like it looked after all the adjusting you did - but if you look at the file on your hard drive it will look like it hasn't changed - because it hasn't.

To create (or overwrite) you select 'Export' and a .JPG is created using the same adjustment script and original image file.

This not only protects the original image but it also helps minimize the artifacts that will occur if you were to do multiple edits to a compressed (.JPG) format image.
 
Excellent, thanks guys.

I also sorted how to get my RAW files to import and look decent...meaning with at least the camera presets applied as a base to work off...by installing these plugins from Matt Kloskowski

http://lightroomkillertips.com/2012/lightroom-4-camera-calibration-profile-presets/

If anyone downloads them (or any other preset for that matter) the easiest way to install them is to drag them right across your desktop onto the LR icon and they install themselves.
 

New Posts


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter
Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom