Liberty Tree Tavern or Chef Mickey's for Dinner?

[beachbunny]

Help. There will be three of us (all adults) going to MK for the day. We want to end our trip with a nice character dinner. Which of the two (Liberty Tree Tavern or Chef Mickey's) would you choose? Also, is the food at Chef Mickey's really that bad (I've read some awful reviews on this board)? And is the food at Liberty Tree Tavern really that heavy (I've heard it compared to Thanksgiving)? DH is a foodie and DSister is a lite eater (likes salads and absolutely nothing deep fried).

 

[DisneyLisa]

I like them both but I think you'd have a better selection for everyone at Chef Mickey's. I've always enjoyed our meals there...no better, no worse than any other buffet at WDW. The atmosphere is great....napkin twirling, Mickey & Minnie, the monorail going through the resort...pure Disney.

 

[BuffaloDisney]

We ate at least 3 times at each retaurant and enjoyed them both.
LTT would get the nod over CM.
We prefer "family style" - LTT
over "buffet style" -CM
We thought the food to be good at both.