Letter to the teacher

Status
Not open for further replies.

Sorsha

<font color=royalblue>People, don't be like the ch
Joined
Feb 26, 2007
Messages
3,716
This is a letter I just sent to DD6's teacher. She is a very good teacher, but not one of my favorite educators I have ever had to deal with. She is so straight-laced, so old school, so sit-in-your-chair and be still. The children are punished for odd little things like not following your words with your finger appropriately when you are reading, and penalized for needing to use the bathroom at inconvenient times. I have put up with it till now, she is the teacher, and I respect her, and Caitlyn has learned well, but yesterday she sent home a scolding little note stating that Caitlyn MUST study her spelling each night and I had to return a signed copy to her. This is not the first time that she has inferred that we just refuse to devote enough time to homework, and I am so over it. I was seriously annoyed, and fired off the following. Did I over-react? I don't want to come off like one of "those" parents... SIGH.

************************

Dear Mrs. XZY,

Thank you so much for all you do for all of our children. Your guidance and your skill show every day. Caitlyn has made great strides this year, and I am very thankful that she has had you for her teacher.

I am writing you this note to make you aware of our schedule after school, and to explain why it may not seem like Caitlyn spends enough time studying or reading at home.

First of all, I am sure you understand when I say I am an advocate of free play time for small children. 6 years old is very young to be expected to spend all day learning and then come home and spend all evening studying. In my opinion, the lessons and skills she learns from free play time are just as important at this age as anything she might learn by extended school work.

Caitlyn and Alyssa have a very long bus ride. By the time they get home in the afternoons, it is 4:15 or later. Caitlyn comes in, grabs a snack, and goes out to play with her friends. Especially now that the weather is getting nicer, she spends most of the evening outside. Imaginative play, physical activity, problem solving, and the social lessons she learns from playtime with her peers are all so very important. At 6 PM, she comes in for supper. We always eat together, as a family, and have a leisurely meal. After supper, Caitlyn goes straight to the bath. This is not only her time to get clean, but also her relaxation and decompression time. It is not unheard of for her to spend the better part of an hour in the tub, playing and singing to herself. At 8 she is out of the bath, and getting ready for bed. Sometimes we read a story, sometimes we watch a little TV together, sometimes, if it fits in, we may study spelling words or look over her school packet. Shortly after that it is time for bed. Caitlyn keeps a very strict bedtime, as I feel her sleep time is important.

On Mondays, our schedule is even more complicated. Both girls take lessons at the gymnastics academy. I feel that organized physical activity is very important, so we have made time for this in our schedule, but it makes Mondays even more hectic!

I hope this give you a little more understanding into our lives. Although it may seem from the outside that we don’t spend enough time on school work, truly it is just that we have set our priorities and we stick to them. I truly believe that a young child’s life should include so much more than reading and spelling. Our values lie in free play, physical activity, and family time. We do try to study the spelling words and read stories together when we have time, but I hope you will forgive me when I say that it just isn’t a high priority in the evening. When a child is small, so much of their learning is done through free play and activities and interactions. 8 hours of formalized schooling should be sufficient for each day. Thank you for your notes reminding us to have Caitlyn study; we will continue to incorporate spelling words into our schedule as time allows.

Again, thank you so much for the time and effort you dedicate to educating our children. You have given Caitlyn such a good foundation for 2nd grade, and it is obvious how hard you work to educate those in your charge. Caitlyn has learned so much this year and I am so grateful for all you do every day.

Sincerely,
Tanya
 
Respectfully, your opinions regarding what's important in relation to your child(ren)'s education make it appear that perhaps you would be happier with her/them in a different type of school, or perhaps being home-schooled? You seem to disagree with the teacher's curriculum - the methods used for ALL students in your daughter's class.

While you feel eight straight hours of education is enough for a six year old in a day - are they really in class all that time, or are you counting transportation time as class time? And while you think it's important for children to learn by playing and to be outdoors and to play in the bath (for up to an hour) to the exclusion of learning to read or spell (basic skills), isn't that also going to put your daughter far BEHIND her classmates in basic learning?
 
Um, interesting.

Ummm yeah interesting... I'm all for play but doing 15min of school work at home never killed anyone.. get her out of the bath after 45min and work on her homework.. this is going to get nasty fast.. just a warning:rolleyes1
 

Honestly I think it is silly to outline your family's entire evening schedule to the teacher. I also think it is a bit odd that your have (based on your schedule) 4 to 4 1/2 hours with your DD from when she gets off the bus until bed and you refuse to make spending 10-15 minutes on school work (spelling) a priority. I do not think kids should be getting hours of homework per night at age 6, and I do feel that unstructured play tiem is highly important for children, but being asked to study spelling words a bit each day is not over the top. If I were the techer I would read that as a long winded way of saying "school is not a priority in our lives at all"--which is not going to win you a lot of support.

Maybe you can write up an extra copy of the list for your DD wach week and she can keep it in her backpack to study while on the bus if you do not want to work with her on it at home.
 
Hmmm. I think the teacher sounds a bit much, and I am not a big fan of homework, but I don't think this letter is going to do you or your daughter any favors.

DS doesn't get home from the bus until 4:30. He always has some homework, a book to read, a worksheet or two to do. They can normally be done in 15 minutes. So he normally comes in, sits down and does the work, has a fast snack, and then from 5 p.m. to 8:30 p.m. is free time.
 
You know what? She's your kiddo, you wrote the letter, and expressed your position.

Done. Over. Your call. Don't be concerned now with what others may think (or at any time, eh)?
 
Just my opinion, but in our house, schoolwork/homework always comes before playtime.

Since the teacher wrote that note specifically to you, it appears that Caitlyn is having difficulties in learning her spelling, and needs more reinforcement at home. So spend a few less minutes playing outside and a few minutes every night doing spelling. What's that going to hurt? Caitlyn may actually start doing better in spelling in school, feel less stressed, and not have to spend time "decompressing".

And this may be a good time to start establishing good study habits at home.
 
From your letter, it sounds like homework is the last priority in your house. :confused3

I agree with you about play time being important, as well as family time.

However, what we do is the kids get off the bus at 3:30, grab a snack, and then chill out watching TV until 4pm.

At 4, the TV goes off, homework is done (and it usually doesn't take longer than 20-25 mins for both of them (3rd and 7th grade) and after that, they are free to play outside with friends until supper.
 
I don't think I would have sent the letter for one reason only. It is none of her business how you spend your time. I commend you for letter your little girl be a little girl. They spend how many hours at school a day? Children need down time. I am a non homework parent. I don't see the point of busy work for the sake of it. If something is not done in class by all means send it home, if it is just extra for the sake of practice by all means send it home and I will send it back with a nice little note saying sorry we don't do busy work.

I do see the need for homework in highschool but not in grade school.

Oh and I am one of "those" parents and proud of it.
 
OP what were her grades like on her report card? honestly my dd7 is a wiz in spelling so we do not study it at home. Maybe your dd is the same way? Mine has gotten nothing but 100's in spelling even though we do not work on it at home... maybe the teacher asked your dd if she does it at home and she said no and wants you to work on it anyway?
 
Since you asked......

Why did you feel the need to tell the teacher about your daily schedule? That was a long letter. What you do at home is irrelevant to the teacher, I think. She isn't going to excuse your kid from the same requirements that every other child has, just because you like to let her soak in the tub and play outside until dinner. There is time for that, plus reading the spelling words. You admit she is a good teacher. Maybe your child is not a very good speller and she is trying to help.
 
Overkill.

You provide so much detail that it sounds a little too defensive.

You can fit in 15-20 minutes for spelling. Spelling is important.
 
I don't think I would have sent the letter for one reason only. It is none of her business how you spend your time. I commend you for letter your little girl be a little girl. They spend how many hours at school a day? Children need down time. I am a non homework parent. I don't see the point of busy work for the sake of it. If something is not done in class by all means send it home, if it is just extra for the sake of practice by all means send it home and I will send it back with a nice little note saying sorry we don't do busy work.

I do see the need for homework in highschool but not in grade school.

Oh and I am one of "those" parents and proud of it.

I think home schooling would be the best option for you.

I'm sure teachers just love you. :sad2:
 
This is a letter I just sent to DD6's teacher. She is a very good teacher, but not one of my favorite educators I have ever had to deal with. She is so straight-laced, so old school, so sit-in-your-chair and be still. The children are punished for odd little things like not following your words with your finger appropriately when you are reading, and penalized for needing to use the bathroom at inconvenient times. I have put up with it till now, she is the teacher, and I respect her, and Caitlyn has learned well, but yesterday she sent home a scolding little note stating that Caitlyn MUST study her spelling each night and I had to return a signed copy to her. This is not the first time that she has inferred that we just refuse to devote enough time to homework, and I am so over it. I was seriously annoyed, and fired off the following. Did I over-react? I don't want to come off like one of "those" parents... SIGH.

************************

Dear Mrs. XZY,

Thank you so much for all you do for all of our children. Your guidance and your skill show every day. Caitlyn has made great strides this year, and I am very thankful that she has had you for her teacher.

I am writing you this note to make you aware of our schedule after school, and to explain why it may not seem like Caitlyn spends enough time studying or reading at home.

First of all, I am sure you understand when I say I am an advocate of free play time for small children. 6 years old is very young to be expected to spend all day learning and then come home and spend all evening studying. In my opinion, the lessons and skills she learns from free play time are just as important at this age as anything she might learn by extended school work.

Caitlyn and Alyssa have a very long bus ride. By the time they get home in the afternoons, it is 4:15 or later. Caitlyn comes in, grabs a snack, and goes out to play with her friends. Especially now that the weather is getting nicer, she spends most of the evening outside. Imaginative play, physical activity, problem solving, and the social lessons she learns from playtime with her peers are all so very important. At 6 PM, she comes in for supper. We always eat together, as a family, and have a leisurely meal. After supper, Caitlyn goes straight to the bath. This is not only her time to get clean, but also her relaxation and decompression time. It is not unheard of for her to spend the better part of an hour in the tub, playing and singing to herself. At 8 she is out of the bath, and getting ready for bed. Sometimes we read a story, sometimes we watch a little TV together, sometimes, if it fits in, we may study spelling words or look over her school packet. Shortly after that it is time for bed. Caitlyn keeps a very strict bedtime, as I feel her sleep time is important.

On Mondays, our schedule is even more complicated. Both girls take lessons at the gymnastics academy. I feel that organized physical activity is very important, so we have made time for this in our schedule, but it makes Mondays even more hectic!

I hope this give you a little more understanding into our lives. Although it may seem from the outside that we don’t spend enough time on school work, truly it is just that we have set our priorities and we stick to them. I truly believe that a young child’s life should include so much more than reading and spelling. Our values lie in free play, physical activity, and family time. We do try to study the spelling words and read stories together when we have time, but I hope you will forgive me when I say that it just isn’t a high priority in the evening. When a child is small, so much of their learning is done through free play and activities and interactions. 8 hours of formalized schooling should be sufficient for each day. Thank you for your notes reminding us to have Caitlyn study; we will continue to incorporate spelling words into our schedule as time allows.

Again, thank you so much for the time and effort you dedicate to educating our children. You have given Caitlyn such a good foundation for 2nd grade, and it is obvious how hard you work to educate those in your charge. Caitlyn has learned so much this year and I am so grateful for all you do every day.

Sincerely,
Tanya

My opinion is that school work can be mixed with play. For example, my DD practiced her spelling word in the tub. We would spray some of the foaming soap on the sides of the tub and she would write with her finger. She also used some of the foam stick on letters to write them. We practiced math facts this way as well.

We also practiced school work by writing with chalk, writing with sticks in the sand/dirt...

My DD's loved to play school (one is now a teacher and the other is an Ed major as well) so this often came out naturally when they played.

As some have said, I'm all for free play as well but learning the basics (reading writing, math...) are important as well.

You're her parent so it's your call but understand that your DD may be behind her peers and the teacher is trying to bring it to your attention.
 
Thanks all, for your input!

Actually, you are right, for a 6 year old, homework IS the last priority in our house. I simply don't feel it is appropriate at that age.

DD9 does have a specific time (while DD6 is in the bath) when we sit down and go over her homework and study it. And of course, DD15 has a HUGE amount of homework each day, and is expected to get it done. But a 6 year old? Nope, not at this age.

Other thing that baffles me is that Caitlyn does fine on her spelling tests?!? Misses a max of 2 each week. I see the tests when they come home, so I am just not sure. She is NOT behind her peers, her report cards have been just fine.

And the reason I have outlined our schedule is that she has mentioned many times how much time she thinks we ought to be spending on school work at home, and I have told her politely, that we are busy and we will fit as much in as possible. She keeps pushing, so I figured it was time to push back.

And truely, NO, I am not happy in this school. We moved into this district this year. Last year my kids were both in a public school that used the Montessori method in all grades up to 4th. It was a superb school and worked wonderfully for us. I miss that school.
 
I just finished student teaching with a full day kindergarten, by the time I left in Dec only 2 had turned 6, so they were a very young group.

Personally, I do agree with you. The amount of work they were given was insane, and they had such little playtime (15 minutes of play inside and 10-15 outside after lunch IF it was nice out and gym only two times a week). Once a week they had Art, Music, Computers, Spanish, and Library.They also had snack time, but MANY times they were working through snacktime, yes an oreo in one hand and a pencil in the other. Needless to say by 1 these kids were DONE! They were tired, losing interest, can't keep their hands to themselves, etc. For homework they were given 2 worksheets (one math sheet and a phonics/letter sheet) and they had to go over 4-5 sight words. I just felt bad for them. I mean it's full day and I understand the teacher's POV too, keep them busy, have an effective lesson ready so they are on task, but I can only imagine it is hard when you 5 and 6 to constantly be sitting and doing some sort of work, KWIM? 20 years ago I went to Kindergarten and it was 1/2 day (thankfully that will be what DD does in the fall, b/c I could not imagine her in school all day).

When parent teacher conferences rolled around I distinctly remember 2 parents comments.
1 set of parents said that their daughter would come home @ 3:30, have a snack, take a nap til 6, have dinner, take a bath and go back to bed. She was so exhausted, the poor thing. Her mom said this continued the 1st month of school and when conferences rolled around in Nov she said she was still doing it about once or twice a week.

Another parent said her son just would cry everyday that he did not want to go and it was too long for him. Seriously, this little guy was a sweetheart and never complained to the teachers, but after I heard this I felt so bad for him.

IDK, maybe I just saw my DD is all of these kids as she will be starting school in Sept, but the days were just pretty long for them.

So, I do see where you are coming from. We actually had one little girl (she was one of 6!!) who was bright and there were some night that she was too tired to finish her homework and her mom would write and put a post it on the homework explaining. My co-op teacher just kinda said, "well you can't force them and if you do it will only upset them," and left it at that. I think if this type of thing should happen again I would just kind of say that is passing to the teacher. Just say we do as much as we can.
 
Thanks all, for your input!

Actually, you are right, for a 6 year old, homeowrk IS the last priority in our house. I simply don't feel it is appropriate at that age.

DD9 does have a specific time (while DD6 is in the bath) when we sit down and go over her homework and study it. And of course, DD15 has a HUGE amount of homework each day, and is expected to get it done. But a 6 year old? Nope, not at this age.

Other thing that baffles me is that Caitlyn does fine on her spelling tests?!? Misses a max of 2 each week. I see the tests when they come home, so I am just not sure.

And the reason I have outlines our schedule is athat she has mentioned may time how much time she thinks we ought to be spening on school work at home, and I have told her politely, that we are busy and we will fit as much in as possible. She keeps pushing, so I figured it was time to push back.

And truely, NO, i am not happy in this school. We moved into this district this year. Last year my kids were both in a public school that used the Montessori method in all graddes up to 4th. It was a superb school and worked wonderfully for us. I miss that school.

If she is missing any words you need to work on it with her plain and simple.. if mine got anything less than 100 she would be doing them at home til she got them like my other dd does. Yes even at 6 she needs to learn to spell! Hello! What happens when she gets to 4th grade and still can't spell simple words?!? :idea:
 
Thanks all, for your input!

Actually, you are right, for a 6 year old, homeowrk IS the last priority in our house. I simply don't feel it is appropriate at that age.

DD9 does have a specific time (while DD6 is in the bath) when we sit down and go over her homework and study it. And of course, DD15 has a HUGE amount of homework each day, and is expected to get it done. But a 6 year old? Nope, not at this age.

Other thing that baffles me is that Caitlyn does fine on her spelling tests?!? Misses a max of 2 each week. I see the tests when they come home, so I am just not sure.

And the reason I have outlined our schedule is that she has mentioned many times how much time she thinks we ought to be spending on school work at home, and I have told her politely, that we are busy and we will fit as much in as possible. She keeps pushing, so I figured it was time to push back.

And truely, NO, I am not happy in this school. We moved into this district this year. Last year my kids were both in a public school that used the Montessori method in all graddes up to 4th. It was a superb school and worked wonderfully for us. I miss that school.

Sounds like your mind is made up.

Why ask for opinions?
 
way too lengthy of a letter. I wouldn't send it.

What age do you find it appropriate to have homework?

My DD is 7 and has to read each night as well as do a worksheet or two. I really don't think a 1/2 hr dedicated to homework is any big deal. Sounds like the school may not be right for you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer

New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter
Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom