Le Cellier OR Tutto Italia

[autismgoesdisney]

I swear I am so bad at these decisions! What do you think?

 

[mermaid&cinderella]

We just ate at both of them last week and I have to say Le Cellar! It was our best meal of the whole 10 days....it was all delicious and our waiter was AMAZING! But Tutto Italia was in our top 5 so you can't go wrong with either of them!

 

[MickeyNicki]

Def Tutto...we can get a great filet anywhere but Tutto has a much better menu and alot more choices too add in cutie patootie waiters and this Italian girl is in heaven!

 

[ROEDISNEY]

No ? for me Tutto

 

[Tam1067]

We had dinner at both in August.

Tutto good is good, but our service was very disappointing--on the edge of rude. I also think it's very, very overpriced for what it is. For 5 of us (on the DxDDP), our meal was $200. Just crazy I think, and if I had to pay, I certainly would have been irritated. As it was, paying the tip on that was too much for me.

Our food at Le Cellier was better, and our service was very good. Also--I do not eat red meat, but the salmon at Le Cellier was excellent and creatively prepared.

One difference for us, which I think really made us prefer Le Cellier is that the servers at Le Cellier were, strange as it seems, proud of the food. Our server talked to us and pointed out some of the regional foods. The Tutto server was very abrupt.

We had to decide between these two for the Candlelight Processional for our Xmas trip, and we decided to do Le Cellier because my 3 kids all preferred to go there.

 

[MouseMomx2]

IMO it's 50/50. They are both fantastic and you can't go wrong with either. Pick the one with the menu that is more appealing to you and enjoy!

 

[Peter Pan Poppa]

You really can't go wrong. They are such different restaurants. Tutto Itallia had some really good choices and it was the type thing that I could have picked about 20 things on the menu. Le Cellier's steak was amazing and the beer cheese soup was exceptional. So I'm recommending....well I can't pick one because they are both great!

 

[Sleeping Becca]

Both are very good, it really comes down to what type of food you prefer. I would agree that it is 50/50.

If I had to choose I would go for LeCellier, just because I love their mushroom filet, cheese soup, and maple creme brulee. I won't say that the steaks are amazing, because they are not, but they are very good and are priced moderately.

Tutto has a ton of good choices but it can get kind of loud in there.

So it really depends what you are in the mood for, 6 months from now lol.

 

[SheilaHeartsDisney]

I thought they were both very good. Our server at Canada was really wierd and thought that since he was being nice and joking with everyone that it was ok to take 20 minutes to take our order and bring us drinks. Our server at Italy was very very nice and was very attentive to us and there was one Italian guy who cleaned the tables who very nice to look at the whole time. His name was Fanceso I would go back to Italy just for him!!! As far as food goes it depends on if you like steak or pasta better. I tend to like pasta better but both places were awesome!

 

[disneypolybride2008]

both are good. We have eaten at tutto 3x and lecellier 2x. We had great service at Tutto except for the last time.. terrible! The waiter was so rude calling me sir, two times! Plus they billed me for my virgin daquiri even though i just asked what drinks i could get. I said when i made the reservation that i was on the ddp and the waiter didnt ask, so i was surprised to get billed for it especially when we ate their earlier in our vacation and i got the same drink! The manager said, just this once, it's NOT on the ddp. Whatever! LeCellier lets u get a mango smoothie and every other restaurant i got virgin daquiris or a smoothie or milkshake! Any whooo... Service has always been good at LeCellier same with the food. Tutto's food was all fantastic, except the veal meatballs and spaghetti was a bit boring for me. Try to do both!

 

[Sleeping Becca]

OMG sooooo true about the waiters at Tutto! Yummy eye candy for sure! lol

 

[loperella]

Disappointed that Tutto didn't have Sachetti anymore but the food was delicious and so was LeCellier. I'd give them both equal on variety, quality but personally liked the atmosphere of LeCellier better and our server (Kate) was the best we had our entire 9 day trip!!! Oh, and the pretzel bread is SO good---heck, it was all good. I feel your pain on this decision, but really can't go wrong with either one.

p.s. the gardens & landscaping at LeCellier also added to the whole atmosphere for me---they were just absoultely GORGEOUS!!!

 

[macmom3]

I've never been to Le Cellier but I only hear great things. I can comment on Tutto and I would say save your money. We ate there last year and didn't like it. We were there a couple of years ago when it was Alfredo's and it was amazing. When they switched owners the server and food quality went down and the prices went up. We ate a better italian meal at Mama Melrose in DS.

 

[DisneyGrampa]

Both are very good-the choice comes down to which menu is preferable. Service related complaints aren't really issues, unless you assume that one of the restaurants specializes in hiring incompetent wait staff. Since LeCellier ADRs are so difficult to get, your choice may actually be made for you!

 

[bytheblood]

Tutto - great food, atmosphere and service.

 

[BingBang]

Must you really, really pick just one? That is a bummer! These are two of our favorite 1 credit TS restaurants in all of Disney. Love the food at both, it probably would depend mostly on which type of food you prefer or what you think you'll be in the mood for. Service at any restaurant can be spotty, so I wouldn't base it on that alone. We've had great meals at both and I'd hate to have to choose between the two. As someone else stated, it may be the ADR (or lack thereof) that makes the decision for you. Good luck!

 

[autismgoesdisney]

We are actually going to try for both HOpe I get them both!

 

[TLSnell1981]

I would definitely choose Tutto!!

 

[Dsny4fun]

I ate at both last month...LeCellier was definatly the better meal.

 

[MJMcBride]

Tutto Italia