Le Cellier or Brown Derby

[GlendaO]

I need opinions please
We've eaten at LC before, and enjoyed it, but it's been years. We've never tried the Brown Derby. We're also using the DDP, if that makes a difference. Thanks!

 

[Meriweather]

We used to eat at Le Cellier every trip but haven't liked it as much the last few years, so stopped.
We have eaten at Brown Derby often too and it is still on our list for every trip.

 

[GlendaO]

We used to eat at Le Cellier every trip but haven't liked it as much the last few years, so stopped.
We have eaten at Brown Derby often too and it is still on our list for every trip.

Thanks!

 

[TiggerTrigger]

We don't feel LC lives up to the hype. I've had much better food and service at Brown Derby.

 

[hooch11bear]

We just ate at both locations a few weeks ago. We hadn't been to LC for a few years either. We loved it!! We always did, but we wanted to try some other TS locations. All three of us got the filet, which was delicious!! We also love BD too. We eat there every year. If I had to pick, I would choose LC. If you can, I would choose both if possible.

 

[Charmagne]

I've never tried either and have ADR's booked for both for my upcoming Disney World trip. Just because you've eaten at Le Cellier, I'd have to say Brown Derby just because you should try something new.

 

[Smposchman]

I prefer to Brown Derby to LC. I think there is just more variety and LC just felt overly crowded. For steak we always to the Yachtsman at the Yacht Club. YUMMY!

 

[NuJoy]

I enjoy the theming of HBD and the cobb salad and grapefruit cake are among the most looked-forward-to treats of my trips.

 

[GlendaO]

Thanks everyone This really helped me make a decision!

 

[GeorgeG]

Le Cellier has been off our list for about five years now. It seems ever since many of the restaurants we used to like went "signature" they have gone way downhill in quality. Many of us "old-timers" blame that on the change in dining plans, but whatever the reason, very few of our old favorites have survived. The same goes for Brown Derby. Several years ago our group of six were there and four of us ordered steaks and the other two went with fish. The fish was good, but the steaks were inedible, even worse after sending them back. I ended up grabbing a sandwich at the cafeteria in the Dolphin. The next evening my wife and I went to Shula's and had great steaks that were only $3 more than Brown Derby.

 

[goofyintoronto]

Between the two i'd definitely pick Brown Derby.

 

[JerseyJanice]

Neither.

If you want to use 2 DDP credits, go to the Yachtsman steakhouse.

We held my parents-in-law's 50th wedding anniversary dinner there, and it was awesome in every way--food, service, atmosphere. Definitely in the Top 3 meals I've ever had.

 

[team bradfield]

Brown Derby, hands down

 

[Vijoge]

Le Cellier was ok. We loved Brown Derby. Next to Jiko, it's our favorite restaurant.

 

[wdwrich]

Another vote for neither. Both LC and Brown Derby are okay, but the signature places at the resorts are far better than those in the parks IMHO.

 

[ggdvc]

I prefer Brown Derby. It doesn't feel as crowded as LeCellier, and the last time we were at LeCellier, I was turned off by our server (she would walk by our table, but stop by the tables on either side to make sure everything was ok). Last year at Brown Derby, a streetmosphere reporter came through the restaurant and "interviewed" my dad about his latest film, and whether the rumors about the stars were true.