Lawsuit against father in death of mother

Originally posted by Chubroach
If it was not my mother in the passenger seat, but someone else who was killed, shouldn't that person's family have the right to sue my father's estate and insurance company? That passenger of the car would be an innocent third party-- just like my mother?

Yes, they could sue. But it wasn't someone else in the car, it was your mother. And it wouldn't be some stranger suing your father's insurance company, it would be you.

I think the attorney is a scumbag for seeking you out, and I personally wouldn't even consider doing such a thing.
 
First of all, I'm sorry for the loss of your parents.

I think CEDmom summed it up perfectly. Take the moral high ground here.

You had mentioned previously that you've been left enough money that you don't have to work to support yourself ever again. So I don't see the point of the suit - isn't "enough" - enough?

If it were me, I would grieve the loss of my parents and would not pursue such an action.
 
It is funny that everyone who I have asked about this that knew my parents says go ahead with the legal action but everyone on this board says NO!

??
 
Originally posted by Chubroach
It is funny that everyone who I have asked about this that knew my parents says go ahead with the legal action but everyone on this board says NO!

??

Not to be rude but maybe they're telling you what they think you want to hear.....

With the facts presented as they were, I find that the money probably won't make you feel better about this tragic situation...and you'll just make some scumbag lawyer richer and make people like us pay higher insurance rates.

Again, it's your call...you need to do what will be best for you.
 

Originally posted by Chubroach
It is funny that everyone who I have asked about this that knew my parents says go ahead with the legal action but everyone on this board says NO!

??

Why do you think that is?
 
Not in a million years would I sue my father - after death no less! -just to rake in a few more bucks. It looks like a complete money grab. Of course this is expected of the lawyer (that's his job I guess) but I am surprised you would consider this. This is a really unnecessary way to raise everyone's insurance premiums. I'm sorry if my opinion sounds harsh but that is how I feel.
 
Originally posted by Rutt and Tuke
I think the DIS is more representative of how a jury would see it than your friends are...

::yes:: ::yes:: ::yes::

This would look like a ploy to get more money. Considering the fact that you have said that your parents left you enough that you would never have to work again.......why would you even consider this?? Take the high road. Don't do it.
 
I agree with Hillbeans - I think you should consider that your friends/relatives are telling you what they think you want to hear rather than how they really feel about it.

As others have said - it's your decision - but you did ask for our opinions, and they've been given. (I mean this respectfully to you and not intended in a negative way towards you at all).

I just know I wouldn't do it. My husband are I are both attorneys and my husband handles selected personal injury/wrongful death cases. He wouldn't touch this one with a 10-foot-pole. Just feels "slimy" and "money grubbing" right from the start.

Good luck in your decision - it's not an easy one.
 
I think the lawyer is morally bankrupt and I would have kicked him in the teeth while I was showing him the door.

I think the sole purpose of this suit would be to enrich the lawyer and yourself, in a rather immoral way, and if other posters are correct about your situation, you don't even need the money. So that leaves the sole purpose as enriching the lawyers.

And folks wonder why our insurance rates continue to climb year after year!

Personally, I think suits like this show just how badly our legal system needs reform.

Stepping off my soapbox. Sorry if I offended, but this just left a really bad impression....
 
I think this whole scenario is highly improbable.


Any good attorney would know that auto insurance policies usually exclude claiims by household members of the insured. since I presume your parents were living together, any claim your mother would have brought against your father would not be coovered by his insurance. So unless there's a reason to move money from his estate to her estate, there's no useful purpose in bringing a suit on her behalf against him.

In many states, the decedent's family has the right to bring an action for the financial harm they sustain as a result of the wrongful death. Usually this means a surviving spouse or children who are financially dependent on the decedent. I'm not sure you could bring such a claim, chubroach.

The only way I could see the insurance company paying would be if you were to sue the driver of the truck. He would be able to sue your father's estate for contribution and indemnity. But the facts as you present them indicate that the truck driver would not be found liable. Your father's insurer would not have pt pay if the truck driver wasn't liable. there's no "contribution" or "indemnity" for someone who isn't required to pay the plaintiff.

So unless there's a reason to move money out of your father's estate and into your mother's estate, the only person who stands to benefit from teh suit is the attorney. And he's duty bound to tell you there's nothing in this suit for you, that it's meritless.

so I don't see the dilemma.
 
I would seek out the advice of the attorney who is handling the estate, and another PI attorney or two. Most PI attorneys will work on a contingency fee and will not charge you for an initial consultation. See what some other legal experts in the field, in your community, think about the claim. If other attorneys think that it is a viable lawsuit, then you just have to detemine whether your conscience can handle bringing the suit.
 
Some good feedback here but some facts and analysis is missing:

The State the accident occured is "no fault" so my father's insurance company will pay the claim.

The household exclusion (family exclusion) or intrafamily exclusion (depending on what you call it) has been declared illegal by the courts of the State in which the accident occured.

Yes, we have talked to other lawyers about this situation and they all maintain there has been successful settlements for accidents that were identical in all ways to the tragic case of my mother and father.

Yes we got a nice amount of money from the estate of Mom and Dad but we would like more. How much is ever enough.

Is there anyone who agrees that this lawsuit is a good idea. (What if drug abuse was involved on my fathers part and it had an impact on his driving that day, would it make a difference in this situation?)
 
I can't think of any circumstances where I would find this morally acceptable. Just because the legal system allows it doesn't mean it's the right thing to do.
 
Yes we got a nice amount of money from the estate of Mom and Dad but we would like more. How much is ever enough.

Well I guess that sums it up. You want more money. Then I guess your choice is made, isn't it? Don't forget you'll be lining the lawyers pocket with benefits from your parents death though.
 
Originally posted by Chubroach

Yes we got a nice amount of money from the estate of Mom and Dad but we would like more. How much is ever enough.


Interesting comment here. I generally don't take quotes out of context but this really bothers me.

I won't post on this issue anymore - you obviously have your mind made up already.
 
Originally posted by Chubroach
(What if drug abuse was involved on my fathers part and it had an impact on his driving that day, would it make a difference in this situation?)

It wouldn't make any difference to me. I think it would still be scummy, but that's JMO.

You're willing to drag your dad's name through the mud for $$. Not something I would do, but to each his/her own.
 
Originally posted by Hillbeans
Interesting comment here. I generally don't take quotes out of context but this really bothers me.

I won't post on this issue anymore - you obviously have your mind made up already.

I don't think you've taken it out of context at all, this is the point he was trying to make, pure and simple. He got some money from his parents death, but it wasn't enough.

How much would be enough? Are you so young that you'll need this money to feed yourself for the next few years, somehow I doubt that is the case.
 














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top