Loved it, loved it, loved it.
Both of my kids DS8 & DD7 went on this GF cruise this past Feb (last summer too) and were immediate fans. They came back with stories of how one of the CM's tried to take over the Pirate Ship and was left as a Cast Away at WDW's old Discovery Island. They were given PBJ sandwiches as a snack. They took home treasure chests filled with loot as keepsakes and WHite & Red striped Mickey Ear Pirate hats.
I always send the kids with Disposable cameras on these things and I ALWAYS get great pictures back.