My girls, 10 and 12 absolutely loved the club/lab, so it really does depend on the child. My 12 yr old also spent time in Edge, enjoying it as well. My 16 yr old enjoyed vibe. We are cruising again this year with the girls as 17, 13, and 11. All they talk about is the clubs. My 17 yr old is thrilled we are cruising again just before her 18th birthday so she has one more time in vibe.