We always stay at the Poly. We usually get our requests and never book anything more than a garden view room. We have stayed in Niue. This is now smoking and since one ds has asthma its out of the question. But if you smoke, its very convenient to the GCH, pool and captain cooks. We have stayed in Aeotoroa. As the other poster says you can get a water view at a garden view price but I dont know how that happened. Good for them, but we got the monorail view garden view. I heard the swoosh of the monorail going by, but I do think those rooms are the biggest or at least seemed to be and the music annoyed me from the luau. Its o.k. once but not if you are there for a week or more, it can get old pretty fast and its a long walk to the pool, laundry and new bus stop. This august we had samoa. I asked for pool view and got 1st floor. I explained ds asthma and wanted him to be able to get back to the room asap if he exerted himself too much swimming. It was perfect for us. We did not notice any extra pool noise. It was a hop, skip and jump to captain cooks for mug runs and snacks. It was a little further away from the new bus stop. We did cut through rarotonga and that bldg. was definetely closer to the new bus stop, so if you have little kids, and are lugging lots of stuff, like strollers, bags etc. You might want to consider that bldg. It depends what you are looking for. I am definetely asking for samoa again or rarotonga (I don't know if this bldg. has been or is due for rehab. Have you checked tikimans site. ). Also if you choose samoa, note that the 2nd floor does not have a balcony.