We just returned from our magical vacation! We did 2 nights at the Poly, 2 nights at the VWL and 4 nights at the BWI CL. We love to resort hop and rent a car, so moving is never an issue. We did decide that 2, 2 and 4 is too much moving though. Next time, we will stick to 2 resorts. Here's a recap:
Poly: Checked in at 11am and our room was ready, but it didn't have a balcony. I asked if we could wait for a balcony room, and the CM checking us in was very accommodating. We got our room about 4pm. It was 2nd floor of Tokelau. We loved it! Great location, beautiful garden view. They were doing some electrical work on our floor, but it did not bother us at all. 2 nights is not long enough at the Poly though
VWL: We had a first floor room, which was ok. We own DVC, but this was our first stay at VWL. We have had very nice stays at WL, but to be honest, there was nothing "magical" about VWL. I felt like it was very remote, no CMs around. Our patio overlooked trees, which is to be expected. I think one of the issues is that our experiences at the Poly and BWI were over the top amazing so VWL came up very short. I think our DD6 has pretty much outgrown the slide, though DS3 loved it. Would I stay here again? Maybe but definitely not my first DVC resort choice.
BWI CL: We saved the best for last!! AMAZING!! We drove over to the BWI about 9am and were greeted by Claudia, who said she would assist us with check-in. She escorted us to the 4th floor Innkeeper's Club and said that she only needed one adult to do check-in and she would bring the rest of the family to the lounge. Initially, we were assigned a King room because of availability. Not ideal given that we have 2 kids, but they were super nice about it and said we would get a Queen room ASAP. I went to the Lounge and a CM came up to me saying they had a Queen room available on the 4th floor right outside the Lounge doors. We took it and it was incredible. Water view, nice view of the BW and we saw Wishes at night
We have not stayed CL since our honeymoon 9 yrs ago. Truthfully, we usually stay DVC but had APs this year and visited WDW a few times so we took advantage of the AP discounts.
Our CL experience was indescribable. Incredibly magical!! The CMs at the BWI CL are really outstanding. We felt like family by the time we were checking out and the kids cried because they were going to miss their new friends
Our family is very outgoing and I think that helps in defining a CL experience. We engaged the staff and in return, we received very special, personal attention. Each time we entered the lounge, one of the CMs ran to get the kids chocolate milk because they knew they loved it. The food offerings were perfect for us. We spent a lot of time at the resort. With such a long trip and given the heat and humidity, we decided we wanted to relax the last 4 days of the trip, so we decided on CL. We still visited the parks but mostly in the morning and later at night.
During our stay, our son celebrated his 3rd birthday and the CL staff sent him cupcakes to the room and a card from Mickey. It was so thoughtful and much appreciated.
We met many amazing CMs, but in particular Tracy was super sweet to the kids and they really connected with her. She has an amazing way with people
Jackie, Pete, Scott, JJ, Anita, Christina and Janice were awesome as well!
Any questions??
Poly: Checked in at 11am and our room was ready, but it didn't have a balcony. I asked if we could wait for a balcony room, and the CM checking us in was very accommodating. We got our room about 4pm. It was 2nd floor of Tokelau. We loved it! Great location, beautiful garden view. They were doing some electrical work on our floor, but it did not bother us at all. 2 nights is not long enough at the Poly though

VWL: We had a first floor room, which was ok. We own DVC, but this was our first stay at VWL. We have had very nice stays at WL, but to be honest, there was nothing "magical" about VWL. I felt like it was very remote, no CMs around. Our patio overlooked trees, which is to be expected. I think one of the issues is that our experiences at the Poly and BWI were over the top amazing so VWL came up very short. I think our DD6 has pretty much outgrown the slide, though DS3 loved it. Would I stay here again? Maybe but definitely not my first DVC resort choice.
BWI CL: We saved the best for last!! AMAZING!! We drove over to the BWI about 9am and were greeted by Claudia, who said she would assist us with check-in. She escorted us to the 4th floor Innkeeper's Club and said that she only needed one adult to do check-in and she would bring the rest of the family to the lounge. Initially, we were assigned a King room because of availability. Not ideal given that we have 2 kids, but they were super nice about it and said we would get a Queen room ASAP. I went to the Lounge and a CM came up to me saying they had a Queen room available on the 4th floor right outside the Lounge doors. We took it and it was incredible. Water view, nice view of the BW and we saw Wishes at night

We have not stayed CL since our honeymoon 9 yrs ago. Truthfully, we usually stay DVC but had APs this year and visited WDW a few times so we took advantage of the AP discounts.
Our CL experience was indescribable. Incredibly magical!! The CMs at the BWI CL are really outstanding. We felt like family by the time we were checking out and the kids cried because they were going to miss their new friends

During our stay, our son celebrated his 3rd birthday and the CL staff sent him cupcakes to the room and a card from Mickey. It was so thoughtful and much appreciated.
We met many amazing CMs, but in particular Tracy was super sweet to the kids and they really connected with her. She has an amazing way with people

Any questions??