Just back from POP--Review

Status
Not open for further replies.

ckmommy

<font color=990099>San Antonio brings out the roma
Joined
Jan 4, 2002
Messages
1,423
We just got back from POP last night. I know that many of you love this resort!! I have to say that I was not impressed with it though. Disney has many, many difererent resorts and not all the resorts will be a match for each family. I do have to say, if this was my first Disney resort, my view may have been quite different.

On to the review---

My DH arrived first with the kids. I was at the Gaylord Palms at a convention. They picked me up after dropping off the luggage in the rooms (we had connecting rooms). I asked my DH how he liked the resort?? He said that we were really far away from everything. I was surprised to hear this because I had read on here that nothing was really too far away at the POP and we had a prefered. We drove in the gate and I loved the huge icons. I knew I was HOME!!! We parked the car and walked to the room--and walked and walked and walked. We had a room in the 60's section (room 5406-07--I think). So where we had to park was a long walk to the room--just grin and walk on!! I finally saw the "flower" pool and thought that it was really well done. We walked onto our room. All I can say is that I felt we were staying at a Super 8. (A foot note to say that my DH does travel for his job, and stays in Hilton brand hotels. While on vacation we generally stay at Hilton hotels because of this. So, I went in the POP thinking that the room would be just under this standard--the POLY was nicer than some of the Hilton's we have stayed in and Port Orleans was similiar to a Hampton Inn. So, like I said I was expecting a little less than a Hampton Inn--anyway....) The rooms were small, the towels, paper thin, the toilet paper horrible. Well, I thought, we do not spent that much time in the room. But, over the course of the week, the overall "cheapness" of the resort started to drive me crazy.

The buses did come about every 20 minutes, but the waits to get on were horrible (one bus coming every 20 minutes--if the first bus becomes full, we had to wait another 15-20 for another bus). This resort has so many people in the ECV's and having 4-5 per bus did get pretty old. I am not complaining about the ECV's or the people in them--I would not want to be in their shoes, but with there being soooo many of them today, WDW needs to find a better way to get people on and off the busses in a timely matter. Maybe two buses at a time (which did happen at the parks during closing time) all the time. It did seem that POP had the most people waiting in line at every park no matter which park it was. We only got to sit down one time on the bus the entire time we were there. It was quite fun for my 2 yo to stand on a moving bus--I wonder how long it wil be for him to ask if he can stand up in the car :rotfl:

The food was good. I did expect the food court to be larger for some reason??? I think the Port Orleans has a much bigger food court. The lines moved fast and the fries were really good. I was really excited to try the tie dyed cheesecake. I was surprised that it was not all cheesecake--but had red velvet cake at the bottom. It was good though!!

One other negative--I was very surprised with all of the smokers that were at the resort. While walking from the food court toward the pool, you get bombarded with smoke from those haging out at the exit smoking. That was a surprise for me. Also, there was a ping pong table set up near the pool bar. Several nights there were people playing beer pong at the ping pong table. Not something that I thought was appropriate for a WDW resort--at bar in pleasure Island, yes, but not at the poolside of a Disney resort.

Sorry to be such a downer, but this resort was not my cup of tea.

If you have any questions, please ask!!
 
The housekeeping did a fantastic job. They cleaned our rooms early (10:30 am) and changed the sheets while we were there--my DS had an accident the first night we were there and it was no trouble to get clean sheets. We were really impressed with the clean factor of our rooms!!
 
I just got back Thursday, and agree with a lot you have said. At least the people you saw respected the designated smoking areas. I saw tons of people smoking right outside their rooms which annoyed me. I also thought mousekeeping was great. Our room was very clean, and the shower was extremely clean!! I never let my kids go near the tubs in hotels, and I actually gave them a bath at POP every day. I have stayed at BWI, GF & Dolphin, so think I might try another next time, just not a value.
 

we drove past pop once and it looked loud and crazy!! i know pop has many fans but for the reasons you stated we stay deluxe and only go once a year. i think those long bus lines and small noisy rooms and lots of smokers would get to me too. i hope you have a better trip next time. :thumbsup2
 
I understand what you are saying, but I still love Pop. For the price, it's a great place.:thumbsup2 I have stayed at Poly & OKW, but they just cost way too much for what you get....IMO.
 
OK, so now I'm freaking. I just switched from ASMo to Pop for my Jersey Week trip. Smokers by the food court, lots of noise and no seats on the bus?! I'm thinking I should call CRO back and switch back or try ASMu.
 
I just got back from POP a couple of weeks ago and while we had a nice time with no complaints, I think I'm more of an All Star girl! I don't know why I prefer them, but I do. I guess for one thing POP seemed more jam packed with people, especially the food court! I've never felt that way at ASMu or ASMo.
 
I was just reading this thread - staying at POP in January. Anyway, saw you were from Ohio too and just wanted to say - GO BUCKS!!!!
 
NJ is a smoke free state well in restuarants etc and you have to be a certain number of feet from the doors.
 
We just got back on Thursday afternoon from 3 days @ POP & didn't find any smokers lingering outside the food courts puffing away whenever we were there. Lots of kids running in & out of the food courts on their own, but that seems to be the norm for the values.

Mousekeeping was great - room was really clean & fresh smelling, although I don't feel that I got the preferred room that I paid for with the hike I had into the back side of the 60's.

My only complaint was the little kids running up & down the halls screaming after 10pm & the neighbor next door constantly slamming his door open & close for about 1/2 hour late at night. Next to impossible to sleep with all that going on.

Bus transportation wasn't bad at all - didn't have to wait very long going to any of the parks. We did stand one morning early going to MK for LOEMH but that was expected. We had breakfast ressies so we piled on with all the families going for the EMH. We also had to stand coming back from MGM but that was because our timing from the boardwalk was just as fantasmic ended. Other than that, no gripes about the bus. We had worse bus transportation at POR. I still enjoy POP for the money & we spent most of our time in the parks.
 
We are also just back from the weekend at POP, and regarding smokers....I was surpised to see that a designated smoking area was right outside the back doors of the lobby/food court. So, if there were several smokers in that area, you did get the strong smell of cigarette smoke as you walked in/out those back doors. We also had neighbors who spent a lot of time sitting outside their room smoking and drinking all night long.

We did like our location (room 4256, "playdoh" building) which faced the lake and was a very quiet location and still near the main pool.

I was impressed with the cleanliness of the resort, including pool-side bathrooms and the pool areas themselves. Each and every CM we encountered was friendly and helpful and I thought housekeeping was terrific.

That all being said, I don't think DH could take another stay at POP...mainly due to the sheer number of people staying there. He doesn't like to come back from a long, noisy, crowded day at the park just to "relax" at a noisy, crowded resort.
 
Sorry you weren't impressed with Pop. I guess this is why Disney has different levels of resorts.

We've been impressed with Pop on our trips. Until we're not, we'll continue to go there. :hippie:
 
We just returned from a 10 day stay at Pop..we loved it!It is a crazy,busy resort,but it is a lot of fun.We stayed at POFQ last year and would take Pop over that any day!
We arrived at noon,and our room was ready,check in had no wait.
The mousekeeping was great,my kids received 4 towel animals,they delivered extra towels when I asked,they were always early.(too early after MNSSHP)
The busses are much better than at PO...the only night we had any wait was at MK,and that was a Spectro night.
I do agree,there was a lot of smoking outside,and on the balconies..not near our room,or I would have said something.The smoking outside the main doors didn't bother me.
The food court was very good...it was crazy busy though.
I did pay preferred,and received a very nice room in the 70's section,it fit the 4 of us just fine!
I guess we all have our own opinions,but I'll save the money and go back to Pop!
 
For people that are planning on staying at Pop or All-Stars please realize that you are paying about $150 a night less than at a Deluxe, please don't be surprise when the resort is not of the same quality. We love the Value resorts started staying in the 1996 when Sports and Music first opened, now my older girls are 24 and 22 and they book Value. They've stayed Moderate and hated it. Too big and too much walking just to get to the Food Court. Youngest Daughter and I have stayed at CR, WL, AKL, and Poly, we splurged and every time I got home I thought that was nice but if I would have booked Value we could've stayed longer. Poly is about 3 times as much per night compared to a Value, you can't compare the 2. Which is great about DIS and other sites, you can research your choice of Hotels.

2 things I don't like about Pop compared to All-Stars. Parking and Pop has over 900 more rooms. More Rooms = more people = crowded buses.
 
For people that are planning on staying at Pop or All-Stars please realize that you are paying about $150 a night less than at a Deluxe, please don't be surprise when the resort is not of the same quality. We love the Value resorts started staying in the 1996 when Sports and Music first opened, now my older girls are 24 and 22 and they book Value. They've stayed Moderate and hated it. Too big and too much walking just to get to the Food Court. Youngest Daughter and I have stayed at CR, WL, AKL, and Poly, we splurged and every time I got home I thought that was nice but if I would have booked Value we could've stayed longer. Poly is about 3 times as much per night compared to a Value, you can't compare the 2. Which is great about DIS and other sites, you can research your choice of Hotels.

2 things I don't like about Pop compared to All-Stars. Parking and Pop has over 900 more rooms. More Rooms = more people = crowded buses.

I have this funny feeling that you may be referring to my post. I am fully aware of the differences between the Poly and Pop. I have no illusions regarding value vs. deluxe. I have stayed at a moderate before as well as DVC and, actually most of the time, offsite. As I have stated on other threads, I have experienced babies crying through connecting doors, children running up and down hallways, door slamming and smokers at the deluxes, specifically the Poly and the Dolphin. These phenomena do not occur only at the value resorts.

This will be our first stay at a value. If I were what is called a "deluxe snob," I wouldn't even consider Pop or AS. I just want to stay somewhere where I can get some sleep after a long day at the parks!!
 
Hey...a little Benadryl, Tylenol PM, or a couple of good drinks can make you sleep great at ANY hotel! :lmao:
 
We're checking into Pop on Monday for an 11-night stay (first time ever to WDW), and I'll have to admit that some of these posts are making me nervous. But I'm sure we'll have a great time anyway! I did have a question for some of you, though. When people are being loud outside your door late at night or smoking on the balcony, can you call to the front desk and have anything done about it? Are there security CMs who monitor the grounds and try to curtail these type of behaviors? Also, on the subject of noise...does anyone know if you can request sound machines or fans for your room to help drown out some of the noise?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.












Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom