Both my kids were in the Club. I have Navigators for the 3-4 age group and the 5-7 age group. I also have all the "regular" ones.
I was surprised by our dining rotation. We had TAPT. Yes, we did get to Palo's (twice). We double-dipped on the night we were in Nassau. We also went the last night and skipped Tritons. The food was very good everywhere we ate. My least favorite was probably Parrot Cay.
Palos was fabulous! We were very luky with ressies. Our sailing was not full, so getting ressies was fairly easy for both the spa and Palos.
I will try and get a trip report up today, but I am happy to answer any questions about the specifics.