just back-AKL Conc. and Poly

luvavacation

DIS Veteran
Joined
Nov 23, 2006
Messages
913
We just returned from 2 nights at AKL-Concierge, Arusha Savannah, Kudu Trail, 4th floor, and Polynesian, Tahiti building, 2nd floor garden view.

AKL was great! The people in concierge were wonderful, pleasant always and willing to get something for you if it was not available at the time you arrived. One afternoon, my youngest daughter and husband were taking a 2 hour nap and my eldest and I were not sure if they would be up for the evening snack offerings (with as much as we spend for food in the parks, we like to take advantage of what concierge food offerings are available if we are at the resort when the food is out). One of the women at concierge said that if they were not up by the time the snack offerings were removed (peanut butter and jelly sandwiches were available at this time, as were other tasty items), she would package up some pb&j sandwiches for my daughter. Sure enough, by the time the DD and DH woke up from their nap, it was evening cordials time, but true to their word, concierge brought out the sandwiches for my daughter! Just an example of how wonderful they were in AKL concierge, I felt they were worth the price we paid, and though the room was smaller than other deluxe resort rooms, we were given a bunk bed room and so my daughters were thrilled, and of course the savannah view is always a plus for us, as we do spend lots of time on the balcony watching the animals. I highly recommend AKL!

The Poly was ok. Check-in was a little disappointing, we did receive the building requested, but not the 1st floor request, instead we had 2nd floor. We were told the resort was completely sold out due to AKL overflow. Oh well, a request is just a request, I was still happy to receive the building I requested. The castmember checking us in was not appearing too thrilled to be at work; we have had more pleasant front desk experiences at Days Inn than at the Poly. He must have missed the training day when they were taught how to smile at guests. ;)

We walked to the Ticket and Transportation Center, since our building was closer to that than the resort monorail, but even after 4 nights there, my DH was always getting lost on the winding paths. It is really confusing after dark, so if you have a bad sense of direction, always carry the map with you!

I really liked the grounds at Poly, very pretty and lush, and our last night there we sat at the beach and watched the Electrical Parade (or whatever it is called!) on the lake, and soaked up some of the evening atmosphere of the Poly. I enjoyed that aspect of my stay there.

The room at the Poly was disappointing. Sure, it is big, and the bathroom is nice and spacious, but we had a few issues that were never resolved, even after I spoke to someone at the front desk. We had a patio door that required superhuman strength to open and close, and even then it would not close completely since the door jam was bent! There was no way to lock it, as the lock would not reach the catch. The walls are paper thin, and the family next door had no problem letting their children bang on the walls at 5:00 a.m. and scream at all hours of the day and night, and every noise outside was heard in our room (could be because the patio door didn't shut!). There were bees, possibly wood bees according to the guy at the front desk ("we don't think they bite, it should be ok") nesting on the one corner banister of our balcony, and a wasp nest just off the balcony in a tree (thus we were not on the balcony much). Also, the left sink's cold water handle was on wrong, it was against the water faucet, not sticking out to the side (how could housekeeping miss this and not have a plumber come fix it?). We called for help with the air conditioner, as it would not stay running, and they sent someone to check on the fridge (?), which was working fine. I figured out how to make the air conditioner work on my own (turn it off and hold it when turning on, then pick a temp).

I did ask to speak to a manager when I initially approached the front desk on our 2nd day there with my concerns, but the manager was not available, yet I was assured that I would be contacted and everything would be looked at and taken care of. Nothing was taken care of, and I was never contacted. I did mention the same concerns again when we checked out, and again the manager was not available, but my concerns about the room were noted, or so I was told.

Of our two hotels stays, and taking into account the other hotels we have stayed at on Disney (Beach Club, Contemporary, Grand Floridian-conc., and Caribbean Beach) our Poly stay was the most disappointing. Of course, this could be because we kept saying that for the money we paid to stay there, we expected more. Our AKL Concierge stay cost less per night than Poly garden, and we felt our AKL stay was still a better experience than the Poly. It just seemed as if the castmembers at AKL, even the ones we met just walking the resort, were friendlier and had more of the Disney spirit than the ones at the Polynesian. Sure, the monorail access was nice, but when we are on vacation and someone else is driving, we don't mind the long bus ride from AKL!

For us, the Poly was not the stellar resort others have experienced, but that is just our opinion, others will differ I am sure!
 
Others before you have reported room problems that were either not fixed, or fixed on the last day. It has got to be extremely frustrating for those of us who love the Poly, and pay the big bucks we do, to not get the satisfaction we feel we deserve while staying there. I for one, am a little concerned about my upcoming stay, considering all the money I have, and will invest, even for a short visit.
If AKL weren't having all these construction issues, I would go there in a minute! Been there before, tho not club level, and loved it!
 
I knew there was something about AKL that I left out - the construction!

Knowing about the construction, we still opted to stay at AKL. The construction was heard during the day, and we heard it while at the pool, but it did not bother us because it did not affect our sleep, since the area we were in was not part of the construction. The floors above us were supposedly being worked on, but we did not hear any of it from our room. If anyone is still slated to be at AKL and has not been moved, I don't think you need to worry about any noise! All was fine regarding that!
 
Sooo glad to here your great AKL Club Level review!! We are staying 3 nights in October!!!
 

Glad to hear you had a great trip....

Now that they have DVC....I can't wait to try AKV concierge....
Sounds like AKL cm's have some pixie dust....

I'm dying to stay at the poly one day....
But unless they have an awesome AP rate....
No Way I'm spending the money....

Always nice to visit though....
thanks for sharing
Kerri
 
I'm so glad to hear you had a good time at the AKL. Nice to hear that the construction didn't affect you. Bummer about Poly, I've been reading a lot of negative threads lately. Unusual since it was always the most loved on these boards.
 
I'm so glad to hear that everything went well for your stay at AKL. We can't wait to stay there!

Your experience at the Poly doesn't seem that far off from what many are encountering lately...which has got to be a disappointment. Was this your first stay there? I'm getting really worried about our upcoming Poly stay...we were switched from AKL which was a disappointment, but were SUPER excited to stay at Poly, but it seems there are a lot of bad stuff circulating about it recently. Makes me wonder if I should try to move my ressie!:scared1:
 
MUDisneyCouple, I wouldn't worry about the stay at the Poly, especially if you were switched there because of construction at AKL. Others have had a great time at the Poly, we happened to not have a great time. It was our first stay there, and most likely our last, but I am glad we went to experience it, even if it wasn't our favorite resort. There were nice aspects, as I mentioned the grounds are beautiful and sitting on the beach at night is really pleasant! And look at it this way - if you get the same room we had, you won't have any of the issues we did, because I complained twice so it has to all be fixed by now!:)
 
Thanks for the good vibes, luvavacation. I think when you hear so much stuff, especially within such a small span of time, it sort of wears on you a bit. I'm so looking forward to our vacation that it will be great no matter where we are! Plus, I do hope we have your room :goodvibes
 


Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE








DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom