Hmmmm....Hard question.
From what my
travel agent told me, Western is better for snorkeling, diving, etc. and Eastern is better for beaches. Do you like sea days? You get one more sea day on the Eastern. We really enjoyed them both. If we were going on another, we'd pick Western so we could try to see Grand Cayman. Really, it is a
Disney Cruise and I'm happy with whatever I get. I think part of what makes the ports fun is what you do there. We did more of the regular tour type things on the Eastern and more adventurous like snorkeling and catamaran racing on the Western, so I thought the Western ports were more fun. There really weren't any great beaches to hang out at on the Western--they were very rocky. However, we just took a water taxi across a bay at St. Maarten and there was a fun beach and we rented a jet-ski.
So, I'd say if you want more ports, better snorkeling, etc, do the Western. If you want an extra sea day & better beaches, do the Eastern. Since they both include
Castaway Cay, I'd really pick based on what week works best for you. It sounds like you love
DCL, so you know you will eventually try whatever one you don't go on next time.
