we were on the Monarch of the Seas docked next to the Magic in Cozumel. We just booked this cruise last min. and didn't want to spend a lot of money because of Wonder cruise in March. We went to national park too and did it on our own. We brought our own snorkle gear and snacks so whole day of snorkling only cost us the price of a taxi and 2 tickets into park. I thought for sure we were going to sink on Fri. creaking and slamming noises all day and night. At one point I think waves lifted us up (our room was right in front of ship, deck 2,)and it felt like we were riding the Tower of Terror ride at DW! I wondered what it was like on the Magic that day and hoped someone would do a report. Sounds pretty much the same as our experience- I am really enjoying your report. Thanks for helping me relive our trip through your report.