Is this shirt too girlie?

coopersdad

Earning My Ears
Joined
May 25, 2005
Messages
28
We leave for WDW in a couple of days. We are having breakfast with Pooh and friends while we are there.

My mom and dad just sent my DS5 this pooh shirt.

My question, is it too girlie for a 5 year old boy?

I appreciate your thoughts.

pooh.shirt.jpg
 
Just my opinion but I think its definitely girly. I personally wouldn't put it on a boy. Although if he likes it and you don't think its girly then I would say let him wear it.
 

Thank you all. You have affirmed my intial reaction.

I think there was a thread of people swaping things, so maybe I can trade with someone who has a girl.

Thanks again, you all are great. :disrocks:
 
I say ask your son. I think we get way too into what is ok for boys and girls. Chances are he is going to say no way but if he wants to wear it and Dh does not object, let him. At WDW there is no one you know anyway!! If you or DH are not comfortable and he wants to wear it let it be a sleep shirt with a pair of boxers!
When my DN was about 5 he insisted on a powder puff girl birthday party! He got it and had a blast. Now at 11 he is all boy and hates to it when we show him those pictures!!'
By 5 however my DS would not even walk down the barbie isle when we had to buy a "girl" gift so he would not had considered wearing it. Just not a big deal at all!!!

Have a blast.

Jordan's mom
 
Hi! :wave:

Yup - too girly. My boys are 4,6 & 9 and they would not put that on...even if it is Disney! :goodvibes
 
Yep...it was in the girl section of the Disney store and DD is wearing that exact same shirt for Crystal Palace breakfast. It's definitely too girly.

The nightshirt idea might work though, if he would wear it.
 
Mom to Jordan said:
I say ask your son. I think we get way too into what is ok for boys and girls. Chances are he is going to say no way but if he wants to wear it and Dh does not object, let him. At WDW there is no one you know anyway!! If you or DH are not comfortable and he wants to wear it let it be a sleep shirt with a pair of boxers!
When my DN was about 5 he insisted on a powder puff girl birthday party! He got it and had a blast. Now at 11 he is all boy and hates to it when we show him those pictures!!'
By 5 however my DS would not even walk down the barbie isle when we had to buy a "girl" gift so he would not had considered wearing it. Just not a big deal at all!!!

Have a blast.

Jordan's mom

I could not agree more with this poster. I would let your son decide. As a mother to two boys, it is often difficult to watch my macho husband tell my little ones that they cannot have something because it is for girls. I will never forget the knock down drag out over a tea set the boys wanted (which incidentally would have been a wonderful tool for beginning training for table manners as well as encouraging imaginative play). THe other thing that concerns me about raising boys and separating things out (instead of letting them choose) is that the separating seems to suggest negative connotations about girls things. They will learn to love and then hate and then love girls again on their own. As their mother, I don't ever want to suggest anything that girls do or like is bad. I want my boys growing up respecting all people. THey learn what is "gender appropriate" from peers, and I never want them to hear from me that this is girlie, and therefore bad. I realize to some this is making a mountain out of a mole hill, but it is important to me that my boys learn these lessons early.

Budly
 
I know my son wouldn't have worn it at age 5....too girly. You could always ask your son, as others have said but it is girly.
 
my son, who is the epitome of boy, would wear it no questions asked! he is very secure in his masculinity (and so are we) and has no trouble wearing what he likes, rather than what the "world" says is appropriate... including *my* "mickey loves minnie" shirt w/hearts and flowers! ergo, i say leave it up to ds! :earsboy:
 
Heck, if you find that shirt in a Large, let me know. I'll wear it! As a guy wearing this shirt at WDW, can you imagine the response you'd get?

ETA: Of course, I'm a big hugger anyway, so this would fit right in with my personality!!
 
hokiefan33 said:
Heck, if you find that shirt in a Large, let me know. I'll wear it! As a guy wearing this shirt at WDW, can you imagine the response you'd get?

GOOD POINT!!! LOL! (maybe i should get dh one too?! the princesses are sure to love it! LOL!)
 
I thought I would ask my ds that was standing here what he thought of it and he said "Your kidding me right mom, that is a girls shirt!!!". So to answer your question, no I wouldn't have either my 3 ds wearing that shirt.
I would love to hear what their dad would say if I did :rotfl:
 
budly said:
I could not agree more with this poster. I would let your son decide. As a mother to two boys, it is often difficult to watch my macho husband tell my little ones that they cannot have something because it is for girls. I will never forget the knock down drag out over a tea set the boys wanted (which incidentally would have been a wonderful tool for beginning training for table manners as well as encouraging imaginative play). THe other thing that concerns me about raising boys and separating things out (instead of letting them choose) is that the separating seems to suggest negative connotations about girls things. They will learn to love and then hate and then love girls again on their own. As their mother, I don't ever want to suggest anything that girls do or like is bad. I want my boys growing up respecting all people. THey learn what is "gender appropriate" from peers, and I never want them to hear from me that this is girlie, and therefore bad. I realize to some this is making a mountain out of a mole hill, but it is important to me that my boys learn these lessons early.

Budly

I wholeheartedly agree with Budly!

Beth
 












Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE











DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top