Hmmm....well now I'm actually a little angry. Backstory...back in January we booked a RO for NYE. We recently found out we are having another baby and I'm due in December so we had to cancel. My due date just cuts it too close. We have another trip (room plus dining) scheduled for September. Since the NYE trip was paid in full and I still owe money on September (I only put the deposit down because I wasn't 100% sure until yesterday that hubby would be able to go) I wanted to just apply the money to the September trip. I talked to two different CMs yesterday and they both said they can only do a refund.
Normally I wouldn't care, but the card I used to book the NYE trip was stolen and canceled by my bank a couple weeks ago. According to Disney if they can't refund the money to my card they will mail a check. We have a super shady mailman and I do not want to be dealing with a check in the mail for the cost of the NYE trip if I don't have to. Thank you for all your replies though! If we are ever in this situation again I guess I'll be more persistent. I know we have been able to apply payments for one reservation to another in the past, but the NYE trip was the first RO reservation we've ever had that we had to cancel.