Is the Yachtsman Steakhouse really that good?

I was looking forward to trying YSH, but now even more after all these great reviews. Just one question, I thought I read somewhere that you can see Illuminations from the restaurant...Is that true?
 
BTW, Deej696 there appears to be something out of sequence in the monorail stops in your sig.

Yeah I know, but I know nothing about that sort of thing to fix it:thumbsup2

And thanks for the server suggestion, I'll have to remember that for next time..
 
I was looking forward to trying YSH, but now even more after all these great reviews. Just one question, I thought I read somewhere that you can see Illuminations from the restaurant...Is that true?

While its true that you can see a few of the Illuminations fireworks bursts from some of the windows, its not a big thing. Just kind of a little extra magic. The key is to be in the rotunda seating area and to be looking across SAB to catch the high ones.
 
We have enjoyed our many meals here also. The masses can keep Le Cellier and we'll continue to enjoy YSH.

I totally agree. We've eaten at Le Cellier in 2006, 2007, and 2008, and I loved it the first time (10/10). The second time, I'd give it a 7/10, and the last time, a 6/10. The last two times, the risotto with my mushroom filet was undercooked and crunchy in the middle. :scared: I hate it when rice or risotto gets stuck in your teeth - totally unappetizing. On the second visit, that great beer cheese soup also tasted as if they used old or spoiled cheese, and the shrimp tasted old as well. It was a pretty unsatisfying meal, but Mo, our server, was great.

On the other hand, we've eaten at YSH in 2007 and had fantastic meals both times. The steaks are always cooked just as we order them, and the meals are timed nicely (not rushed or dragging). We've taken my niece, two and a half at the time, once and she did well also. We are planning to visit YSH next May, and we have no plans to visit LC again soon. It's a perfectly okay restaurant, but it's not outstanding - we think YSH is. As another poster mentioned, I don't care for their desserts, but the appetizers and entrees are simply wonderful. Also, we have always made our ADRs for 5:30 - when YSH opens - and usually get in right away. Going at opening may help people get in on time, but I know that timing isn't always ideal or possible for people. Go and enjoy! :)
 

I went once with my exhusband and I remember it being just ok. That was probably 3 or 4 years ago though.
 
LOVED IT !! If you see what I put about the dress code, that was the only negative I saw.

I got the big steak ($60.00) I believe and it was incredible !!! It was the second best steak I have ever had right after Delmonico in Las Vegas. That place is the place I compare steak to because it is just that good.

Daughter got the steak and hers was great too !!

Wife got the filet and loved it too !!

I would go there and try it because it was worth it !!
 
We just ate there last week and it was fabulous! DSIL and I ordered the waghu beef which was excellent. I have never had it so I wanted to try it.
 
The Yachtsman was where we celebrated our 25th anniversary in Sept. It was our first time there and we both loved it!

Our server was great, the food was fabulous and the onion rolls were out of this world! (somehow :confused3 a few extras ended up in my doggie bag :woohoo: )

We will be returning on Jan 24th, our first night at Disney for our trip. First choice for both of us :) This time though, we are skipping appies to go for dessert :banana:
 
Yes, it's really that good. Beats Le Celliar hands down!
 
My favorite item on the menu is the Chateaubriand Steak for two and my favorite server is Susan D. You will love it!
 
But can be requested if you ask your server to ask the Chef.

I wonder if somebody that knows the Chef could find out if the Wagu beef is going to be available on the 1st. :wizard:
 
It's great to hear such good reviews! We are now going to go for the first time for our May trip. It sounds wonderful!
 
I wonder if somebody that knows the Chef could find out if the Wagu beef is going to be available on the 1st. :wizard:

Not sure what inventory will be - BUT ask your server to check with the Chef. Can't hurt to check!

I'm on my way to fly in to FL in about 6 hours if the Northeast snow lets me get out of NY.

Have a great New Year's everyone!!!!
 
Yes, we celebrated our 30th anniversay there and it was absolutely wonderful. They found out it was our anniv and the waiter and staff we great. They asked us to wait for another minute as they had a special table for us. We were so full we couldn't eat desert, the chef said no we must have something that we couldn't celebrate without, so he sent sample cookies deserts to the table. They were grat and we had a wonderful evening. Food is out of this world:goodvibes
 
Favorite meal of our trip. My husband and fifteen year old daughter and I had a great dinner while the two littlest spent a couple of hours in the Sandcastle club. My fifteen year old shared with my husband and I since she is not a bigger eater and it was more then enough food. HS got the Fliet and I had their lamb dish (wonderful). I also had a wonderful beat and fried goat cheese salad that I would go back for in a minute. We did not have any trouble with crowds or long waits but we tend to eat early and then hit Epcot.
 
I wonder if somebody that knows the Chef could find out if the Wagu beef is going to be available on the 1st. :wizard:
Be careful what you ask for. Have you had it there before?

First, my general opinion. If I had to sum YHS up in one word, based on our one experience, it would be.............Eh. It was ok, but it wasn't great. Our last trip included meals at YSH, Citricos, Narcoossees, and Le Cellier, among others. YSH was the worst of the bunch, and we will not be in any hurry to go back. I do have quite a bit of steakhouse experience, including chains such as Mortons, Ruth Chris, The Palm, along with excellent local steakhouses such as Bern's (Tampa) and most of the NYC biggies. So I can tell a really great dining experience from an average one when it comes to steakhouses. Maybe we just hit an off night, but that wouldn't explain everything. One of my biggest complaints abou the place, and an area where I'd expect much more from a fine dining experience, was the sides. I will agree that the actual cut of filet you get there is excellent, better than Le Cellier or any of the other meals. My wife's was also cooked properly. But the sides! Ugh, the sides. With that great filet you get a lump of average at best mashed potato.

Now back to that Wagyu beef. I had it. It was very disappointing. This may be where the bad night came in, I really don't know. That's also why I ask if you've had it already. For starters, my cut was a little undercooked for my medium rare taste. No big deal, I can do rare. My problem was the cut itself. Yes, I realize that Wagyu is higher in fat and marbleization than other steaks, and I was properly informed by our server of this fact, but I like that. I'm a NY strip fan because I like the flavor the fat gives. But this cut didn't just have marbleization. I think it's a 10 oz cut, but I had to leave at least two oz on the plate, a hugh amount of fat along one side of the strip. Just an almost inch thick slab of pure, inedible fat. To me that is just bad butchering. As for the rest of the piece of meat, it was tender and flavorful, but my cut had a hugh seam running through it, which made it unpleasant to eat. Again, bad butchering. In such a well regarded steakhouse that sort of butchering is unacceptable. Oh, and while my mashed potatoes had truffle oil in them, they were still average at best.

So, between the so-so sides, and my bad cut of expensive Australian beef, our overall experience was average at best. Sure, the actual piece of filet might be better than Le Celliers (but we're really splitting hairs here), but the overall experience at Le Cellier was much better....as it was at Citricos (a filet to rival YSH, with better sides).....as was Narcoossees.
 












Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top