Honestly, you will have a magical time at either place! My experience is this. I've lived close enough to frequent the parks most my life where I didn't need a hotel. Then 10 years ago we moved to northern california and our trips require a hotel stay (I won't go for less than 3 days...hehehehe)
We have always stayed at a Harbor/Good Neighbor hotel and have had wonderful and memorable trips. Then last Feb. we did a last minute trip, got the Grand for 260.00 a night, had a little extra money to do so and went for it!
IT WAS AMAZING!!! I honestly think that the whole experience was well worth the money. Here are the things I thought all added up to what I felt was worth it:
~The hotel was beautiful, from the lobby to the grounds, from the pools to the spa we really enjoyed ambiance.
~How close we were to the action. No matter where we went it was only a few steps and we were there!
~The choice and different styles of restaurants were great. We loved the storytellers cafe, with the characters.
~Whitewater snacks was awesome for a quick snack or lunch...way more than I excected.
~The fireside evenings and the piano playing was my absolute FAVORITE. I'd leave our hotel room door cracked and fall asleep to my favorite Disney songs being played by the baby grand.
It was an amazing experience and I can't wait to do it again. We do several trips a year so for now we just wait for the right time
Again, you will totally have a blast no matter where you stay...good luck in making your choice
