No. Different day is definately not going to work (and most CM's would notice).
Later in the same day (i.e., past your window) is unoffically acceptable. Many people dislike the practice, but most CM's will allow it to pass, especially if you are up front and nice and ask first instead of trying to "trick" them. I've never been turned away after saying, "This expired...is there any chance?", but I have occasionally see more rude people try to bend them or otherwise trick the CM and not be as lucky.
NED